So this will be like majority of people predicted, Horizon>Zelda graphics while Zelda>Horizon metacritic and sales.
I must sale that both predictions from OP, that Horizon will win Zelda on metacritic and sales, were very bold easily said, especially for point that Horizon will win Zelda on metacritic.
Also it was not hard at all for Horizon to beat technically Wii U game from technically graphic side, when PS4 is so much stronger than Wii U, but IMO Zelda BotW because great art style still look phenomenal even from technical side Horizon graphic is much advanced.