By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Metacritics unbelievable Bias against Nintendos Thirdparty exclsuives in recent days

fireburn95 on 18 November 2015
Dravenet7 said:
fireburn95 said:


How the f am I supposed to know whether OP is a nintendo fan or a jamaican or a federer fan?!

But a statement such as the title and the ridiculous justification of it IMPLIED it was a nintendo fan who feels they deserve a great review just because it is a nintendo published game, even though MC is aggregated scores, so if metacritic is somehow biased, it might be to do with the fact 20+ reviewers didn't like it, as is their right to do so.

For your question, you can:

1. Ask

2. Check his/her profile

3. look at the comments in the thread

So you can't be a Nintendo fan, a Federer fan and a Jamaican at the same time, or is this a very poor and exagerated attempt at implying that it is near impossible to figure whether he/she is a Nintendo fan despite the availability of #1-3, with #3 literally given to you?

Regardless you say in your latest response it was a implied that a Nintendo fan (singular) wrote this complaint. Yet, in your first comment, you comment about Nintendo fans (plural) in a generalization rather than that specifically implied Nintendo fan. Its also clear you are generalizing instead of specifying because your first comment clearly expressesses your suprise at the op's title and what's written, and projecting that individual's thoughts to Nintendo fans in general. There is nothing you wrote, implied or otherwise, that implies otherwise. Which really doesn't make sense to write becasue many thus far, which clearly includes a established Nintendo fans, have disagreed with the op's viewpoint.


I have a life dude... not worth learning everybody's preference's before i state an opinion

Way too much analysis of a mere comment...I recommend getting some action...Plural

- Moderated - Tachikoma



Around the Network
fireburn95 on 18 November 2015
ClassicGamingWizzz said:
Yes , totaly bias, disgusting behavior from the gaming press, all nintendo games get crushed by the bias gaming press. Devils third is amzing and deserved 90 plus scores, look at that graphics, that awsome gameplay , story and AMAZING characters . Bias


:P



V-r0cK on 18 November 2015

Metacritics just takes the average.

Seeing Fatal Frame average reviews and user reviews doesn't seem that far off from each other but I guess they're all biased?



Goodnightmoon on 18 November 2015
fireburn95 said:
Dravenet7 said:

For your question, you can:

1. Ask

2. Check his/her profile

3. look at the comments in the thread

So you can't be a Nintendo fan, a Federer fan and a Jamaican at the same time, or is this a very poor and exagerated attempt at implying that it is near impossible to figure whether he/she is a Nintendo fan despite the availability of #1-3, with #3 literally given to you?

Regardless you say in your latest response it was a implied that a Nintendo fan (singular) wrote this complaint. Yet, in your first comment, you comment about Nintendo fans (plural) in a generalization rather than that specifically implied Nintendo fan. Its also clear you are generalizing instead of specifying because your first comment clearly expressesses your suprise at the op's title and what's written, and projecting that individual's thoughts to Nintendo fans in general. There is nothing you wrote, implied or otherwise, that implies otherwise. Which really doesn't make sense to write becasue many thus far, which clearly includes a established Nintendo fans, have disagreed with the op's viewpoint.


I have a life dude... not worth learning everybody's preference's before i state an opinion

Way too much analysis of a mere comment...I recommend getting some action...Plural

Better to shit about a whole comunity just in case. I get it.



Dravenet7 on 18 November 2015
fireburn95 said:
Dravenet7 said:

For your question, you can:

1. Ask

2. Check his/her profile

3. look at the comments in the thread

So you can't be a Nintendo fan, a Federer fan and a Jamaican at the same time, or is this a very poor and exagerated attempt at implying that it is near impossible to figure whether he/she is a Nintendo fan despite the availability of #1-3, with #3 literally given to you?

Regardless you say in your latest response it was a implied that a Nintendo fan (singular) wrote this complaint. Yet, in your first comment, you comment about Nintendo fans (plural) in a generalization rather than that specifically implied Nintendo fan. Its also clear you are generalizing instead of specifying because your first comment clearly expressesses your suprise at the op's title and what's written, and projecting that individual's thoughts to Nintendo fans in general. There is nothing you wrote, implied or otherwise, that implies otherwise. Which really doesn't make sense to write becasue many thus far, which clearly includes a established Nintendo fans, have disagreed with the op's viewpoint.


I have a life dude... not worth learning everybody's preference's before i state an opinion

Everyone has a life, but if you're gonna make cheap generalizations when the information is right there and then defend this by subsequently consume more time defending your generalization then it takes to look at the very next comment, or even see the op's sig, then you yourself are willingly wasting your life away making innacurate generalizations. Claiming you have a life doesn't make sense when your wasting it yourself

EDIT:

I noticed you edited this in to your comment: "Way too much analysis of a mere comment...I recommend getting some action...Plural" 

This, of course, is the rational thing to do. When someone, points out what you are saying is wrong over general opinions in video games and groups, you decide to attempt to attack that person on a level which you know nothing about? Are you serious? This legitmately childish 



Around the Network
teigaga on 18 November 2015
Ruler said:

Rodea the Sky Soldier, 48

Devil's Third, 44

Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water, 67

meanwhile Indie games get 90s regullary who look worse in every aspect of quality. Just proves it even more that Metacritic is not reliable when it comes at rating japanese games in general (Famitsu, 4gamer and other japanese reviewers not allowed) but its even worse for nintendo games not made by Nintendo it seems.

Tell me what you think? do you agree whith these scores? i feel there is something fishy

Indie games are not scored like big releases, they cost like $10. Your same arguement can be used to say the press are bias against Playstation Exclusives seeings as most score below 90 where as"Indie games regullary who look worse in every aspect of quality".

I think the way western press  treat Japanese games is fine, note how these same games all bombed in Japan aswell. Its  for consumers to understand what their tastes are like and know that maybe some things that reviewers dislike, you maybe love. 



Dr.Henry_Killinger on 18 November 2015



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

Shikamo on 18 November 2015

for me rodea the sky soldier on wii u is 5/10 and on wii is 8/10, wii version is tooo much better than wii u version



     


 (=^･ω･^=) Kuroneko S2 - Ore no Imouto - Steam, MyAnimeList and Twitter - PSN: Gustavo_Valim - Switch FC: 6390-8693-0129 (=^･ω･^=)
Platina on 18 November 2015

First 2 games aren't that good from what I have seen though Fatal Frame does sound interesting..



NintenDomination [May 2015 - July 2017]
 

  - Official  VGChartz Tutorial Thread - 

NintenDomination [2015/05/19 - 2017/07/02]
 
          

 

 

Here lies the hidden threads. 

 | |

Nintendo Metascore | Official NintenDomination | VGC Tutorial Thread

| Best and Worst of Miiverse | Manga Discussion Thead |
[3DS] Winter Playtimes [Wii U]

fireburn95 on 18 November 2015
Dravenet7 said:
fireburn95 said:


I have a life dude... not worth learning everybody's preference's before i state an opinion

Everyone has a life, but if you're gonna make cheap generalizations when the information is right there and then defend this by subsequently consume more time defending your generalization then it takes to look at the very next comment, or even see the op's sig, then you yourself are willingly wasting your life away making innacurate generalizations. Claiming you have a life doesn't make sense when your wasting it yourself

EDIT:

I noticed you edited this in to your comment: "Way too much analysis of a mere comment...I recommend getting some action...Plural" 

This, of course, is the rational thing to do. When someone, points out what you are saying is wrong over general opinions in video games and groups, you decide to attempt to attack that person on a level which you know nothing about? Are you serious? This legitmately childish 


An attack?! Lol cute, you must be a SJW i'm guessing...Words hurt do they?