By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - So I just built a PC and here's my take on the whole Consoles VS PC argument

Lawlight said:
Ka-pi96 said:
Lawlight said:

Which of those is a lie?

Most of them. I've never had to fiddle with drivers/settings etc. Get the odd time where a game won't start until I've downloaded a driver update but that's not exactly hard. Besides, speaking of updates 99% of the time they are automatic anyways. Windows does most of them automatically, usually including driver updates. While Steam auto downloads any necessary game updates. PS3 only does that if you pay for PS+, while I'm not aware of either the PS4 or Xbox One being able to do that yet. So that 'frequent updates required' thing isn't really a thing. Updates are done much more in the background and you rarely notice them, same can't really be said for consoles. As for extra space... well you know a laptop could be used for PC gaming too right? Besides I expect the vast majority of people already have a computer + desk for other purposes anyways so it's not as if it's any more space than was being taken up by your old PC anyway.


1. Just a random example, Google The Witcher 3 PC issues drivers, you'll get plenty of hits.

2. I said frequent upgrades, not update. Updates are done in the background for the PS4 as well.

Gaming on a laptop is the most uncomfortable thing ever and you're still left with the final issue. So. I think all of them are true.

3. And gaming at a desk, cut out from your partner or family, who wants that? I know I did when I was a teenager.

1. Consoles have similar problems with games. Just look at the number of updates they need these days and some never get fixed (google Skyrim PS3)

2. Completely false considering a mid-high tier PC from March 2012 is still capable of playing equivalent games at higher settings and resolutions than PS4 (that's mine btw; Core i5 2500K, 8Gb RAM and an AMD HD7870).

3. It's 2015, not 2000. There are plenty of controllers, case designs and interfaces to make gaming on a couch and TV a viable option. Valve are introducing a bunch of PCs just for that.



Around the Network
zero129 said:
Lawlight said:


I'm sure more PCs had performance issues than PS4s. Just maybe not your PC.

Yes cos my PC is some magic PC am i right? xD .

Also in reply to your post to Conina about The Witcher 3 issues.

A Driver issue is still pretty much a Software issue as once you update the driver the problem is fixed. How long did Sony fans have to wait for performance to become stable on the PS4? like it is on the PC from the start.. thats right it was with Patch 1.10 and when was that patch released? why only this month!!.

No, you're just lucky, I guess.



AnthonyW86 said:
zero129 said:
AnthonyW86 said:
I've noticed that PC gaming seems to shift a bit more to budget these days. And the hard fact is, development in PC hardware just hasn't been that fast or interesting in recent years.

I used to be a real PC hardware fanatic, upgrading on a regular basis. But now i have a PC that i upgraded for the last time 5 years ago. And it's sitting still ever since i got a PS4.

I think that's a big issue to these days, there just isn't that much for hardware enthousiasts to be enthousiastic about.

I think one of the biggest parts to play in this is that with the consoles launching with such low specs not many devs are really willing to push games on PC other then better textures, res, draw distance lighting etc etc. But then in a sense thats really all the nextgen consoles offer above the lastgen. This is the very first gen i have not felt the need to own one of the nextgen consoles thanks to my pc. Every other gen one of the new consoles would end up being more powerful then my pc with games looking better then i could play on it unless i spend big bucks. But that trend changed this gen imo.

I agree with you that this gen is less high gen then other games, and yes that does mean you don't have to spend as much on a PC to get a ''next gen'' console like experience. But that's not all, progress in PC power has just slowed down a lot in recent years. Especially price-performance wise.

Let me give an example: I still have a AMD HD5850 1gb in my PC. That card launched 6 years ago in 2009, and cost about € 230. It was the most popular card back then.

Right now the most popular card in that price range is probably the Nvidia GTX 960 2GB. That card is just about twice as fast as the HD5850, and it has twice the memory etc. So about a doubling in price/performance in 6 years.

Now if i look back to 6 years before the HD5850 in 2003, i owned a Radeon 9700 128mb AGP. Know that card cost about € 300 euro's. Comparing that to an HD5850 it is probably about 20 times faster than that 9700, and it packs almost ten times the memory. And it's actually cheaper to.

As you can see there has been a huge slow down in progress. And looking at consoles allthough PS4 uses a mid-end gpu from well over three years ago, a current € 200 9600 GTX is barely any faster. Again compare that to an HD5850 witch released three years after the PS3(a console with higher end specs), the HD5850 runs circles around the PS3's 7800/7900 gpu and has twice as much video memory as an entire PS3 system(at 5 times the speed).

To be fair, GPUs are due a die shrink. It feels like they've been stuck at 28nm for a long time.

I also think you're seriously underestimating the performance difference between the GTX960 and HD5850.



vivster said:
So we have one game on PC that is bad and an entire library of gen 8 console games that runs like shit.
I think you convinced me.

This thread is basicallyturning into that which is a darn shame.

And of course it had to turn into a typical PC vs console thread by a few in here that have always hated PC and just came in regardless, what is the point in that at all?, I don't like the PS4 and don't desire an XB1 yet I don't hop in those threads hardly at all. I came back from a small hiatus and decided to comment on a few select threads and here was me thinking things would change.



Mankind, in its arrogance and self-delusion, must believe they are the mirrors to God in both their image and their power. If something shatters that mirror, then it must be totally destroyed.

zero129 said:

I dont know with the way some things where worded in the OP **CoughPCElitestCoughHiddenCostsCough** , Being in the gaming section instead of the pc section, it was like it was destined to turn out this way .

I figured from the start which was kinda why I jumped in to have my say but there are definitely some folk on here who have previously stated their dislike for PC's and PC gaming in general, they really shouldn't be poping into this sort of thread to make it a proper PC vs consoles argument and trying to turn it completely into consoles favour but then again the OP worded things towards the can of arguments that were going to come in and also titled it as such which also begs to invite users who were against PC gaming anyway.

Like it's really no secret that I have no interest in the PS4/XB1 but I'm still not likely to jump into their mega threads or system label only threads to downplay what they are talking about.

I mean at the end of the day we should just game on what we like and all that jazz than being at each other's throats and constantly indulging in the downplay game but at the same time getting the facts straight.



Mankind, in its arrogance and self-delusion, must believe they are the mirrors to God in both their image and their power. If something shatters that mirror, then it must be totally destroyed.

Around the Network
zero129 said:

True. And trust me, i know the is users on here you hate pc gaming for some reason as if its going to take away all their toys.

Just look here at the comments http://www.vgchartz.com/article/261562/steam-sets-new-record-with-1076-million-concurrent-users/

 

Look what comments got liked and then look at TheGreatGamerGod who got 3 dislikes for saying "Indeed, this also of course doesn't count the offline users. I tend to use it offline more than online to avoid perky conversations during larger games so it could well be a lot more." in a reply to JRPGFan asking "Does this mean they had close to 11million people with steam opened up?". But yet Lawlight got 3 likes for saying "So, anyone who's got Steam opened in the tray but not playing counts as a concurrent user?"

Ofcorse i tried to even out the likes a bit so now he only has 2

Also i wouldnt leave if i was you. At the end of the day if we or users like us are not here to defend PC gaming from such clear smuge campaigns people might start believing the words that come out of most of the pc haters moutes. Best to just make users see them for the sillyness that they are.

I think in some of the haters cases anyways why they fear pc so much is that so many of their friends maybe want/plan on getting a PC. At the end of the day TF2, CSGO, Dota, WoW, and even Minecraft PC version (Thanks to mods) are much bigger exclusives (Even if Minecraft isnt exclusive you cant even compare the console versions to the PC version)then a lot of console fans will try to make out, and them 5 games alone are bringing many a console fan to PC, never mind the other wealth of classics to new AAA games to being able to play pretty much any game from any system up to lastgen is making it a most have gaming device for many a once console gamer. IMO this is what the haters fear and is why they hate it as i cant think of any other reason other then losing your friends to another device that you dont have that could make you not like that device in such a way (Im not saying every console fan is losing their friends to PC only the haters).

See the more I see this site when it comes to PC news the more I see a waste of effort, for a time I watched when PC article came out to see how fast VGC can catch up on PC type news than say PCGamer does or Dtoid and other sites but even when they do the comments are pretty much empty until it;s something PC gets or has acheieved is when downplaying comments come into play and it just speaks volumes of how much the site cares for PC gaming, that is to say it's not entirely a welcoming place or users making you feel unwelcome.

I love PC gaming for what it offers and what is is, I've always loved playing some games on my PC's through the years from being a kid to now and played consoles in the past as well but now I just don't see that being a thing this gen (except for Wii U) and decided to fully keep with PC, I don't care what people play on tbh but I do care when they try to butt in and make excuses as to why their lack of giving PC a try is somehow better than not trying it at all and that's what I will never understand from these people who choose to constantly come in and downplay and then claim we downplay them all the time (because lets face it that's always going to be one of their backup arguments even though we lack PC users on the site to begin with).

You know what was funny though, a few weeks ago I ordered a new PSU and GPU (GTX 980 AMP edition and EVGA 750w) and once they arrived I thought I wasn't going to get it right plugging them in since my last PSU had a different layout but in the end I got them both sorted and it really is building with legos (I notcied that legos image in a PC related thread a few days back =P).

Also recently thought of upgrading my ram since I'm feeling 8gb isn't enough for me, I don't do video editing yet but I do use animation software and generally like to keep some clients open and over the years I have become memory and process obcessed so I like to keep usage and consumption as low as possible. Wondering where to get a nice kit of 16gb (high quality) though since I could use PC parts picker but I've noticed they don't always have the kits I'd love to use, I could probably just use Scan.co.uk instead though.



Mankind, in its arrogance and self-delusion, must believe they are the mirrors to God in both their image and their power. If something shatters that mirror, then it must be totally destroyed.

PS4 MASTERRACE



TaMpAbLaCk said:
PS4 MASTERRACE

AMD APU RACE



My Etsy store

My Ebay store

Deus Ex (2000) - a game that pushes the boundaries of what the video game medium is capable of to a degree unmatched to this very day.

Lawlight said:
zero129 said:
Lawlight said:


Actually, with the PS4, it's all done in the background but you're still not going to run into issues running the game. There's a plethora of issues that you could run into with a PC.

What's not fun about gaming on a PC (other than the library missing games that I want):

- constant fiddling with drivers, settings, etc.

- frequent upgrades required.

- requires extra space to set up the desktop, monitor, input devices.

- having to play with kb/m in MP just because everyone else is.

 

Which of those is a lie?

 

I'll give it a go;

1: Constant fiddling with drivers and settings. No, I update my graphics drivers about once every two months or so, the process is entirely automatic and can usually be performed in the background. Drivers for motherboard, sound card, HDD and SSD, optical readers and network gear is usually out of the box and practically never needs updating. GPU's are the only components which require frequent or semi-frequent updating. The firmware updates and various app updates on consoles are an equal hassle, sometimes more since the servers are terribly slow (especially on PS). I've also experienced not being able to play a new game at all (GTA V) because I lacked the newest firmware on my PS3 when I was without a connection for 2 months, the game simply would not start and I was forced to bring my PS3 to a friend's house across town, ride 30 minutes of trains and bus each direction simply to update it, this has never happened to me on PC ever since we entered the modern era of gaming (I've also spent 3-4 hours waiting for Gran Turismo 5 and 6 to update after not having played them for a while).
As for settings; I'm assuming you're talking about games here. Never have I "constantly fiddled" with settings in games, I buy the games, install them and then choose every setting and bind the keys and then I play the game, usually never touching the setting ever again until I'm done with the game, so that part is an outright lie at least.

2: Frequent upgrades required; no. I had my last rig for 5 years and it was in the upper middle segment of performance when I bought it, I never so much as replaced a single component in it. It was still fully functional and even ran the newest games, but I wanted more oomph and decided on a new one (and went balls-to the walls). This is among the favorite arguments of console gamers, but it's also an outright lie. Frequent upgrades are not required, my current rig can probably go for 7-8 years if I add another GPU on SLi setup, with no other components replaced, it won't max them but run them at least (1080p and unstable 30 FPS console gaming isn't anything to shower with pride either imo).
I guess it comes to to your definition of "frequent", but to me, every 5 years or so is not frequent, that's actually more or less in line with most console lifecycles for early adopters (with One and PS4 being exceptions and not the rule, PS3 and 360 had unnatrually long lives due to the HD era being ushered in).

3: Requires extra space to set up desktop, monitor and input devices. My monitor is huge (32") and my desktop is a Big Tower as well, it easily fits in my 1 room appartment of around 37 square meters though, and I also have a 46" TV here. My input devices are as follows; a Logitech 2.1 system with the small speakers placed on each side of the monitor on my fairly small desk and the bass placed directly below on the floor, an HD camera for Skype on top of the monitor and currently a Xbox 360 controller I use for FIFA. That's not really a terrible hassle and my screen and tower is vastly bigger than average. Besides; the TV + console + possible surround takes up a lot more room, so this is a non-argument at best and seems like serious grasping at straws.
If you can't afford living conditions that will fit a desk and a desktop computer, you probably don't have cash to spend on console gaming and a decent TV either.

4: Having to play with kb/m in MP just because everyone else is. Another non-argument; "the majority of users are using a controller setup I don't like, the platform is unfit for me." That's just personal preference. I hate playing FPS games and most RPG's with controllers, that doesn't mean that I complain about people playing Battlefield on PS and Xbox and state that I can't buy those consoles because other gamers are using controllers I don't like.
Keyboard + mouse is superior in every way on FPS and 3rd person games, as well as RTS and RPG's with lots of shortcuts and hotkeys; the fact that you don't like it personally is not an argument against PC gaming in general from any objective standpoint.

These are not proper arguments at all, they're either false or simply completely subjective and/or irrelevant. It's fine that you don't appreciate or like PC gaming, I can understand it on some level, but the above points are not fit to dismiss PC gaming as a whole.
There are a hundred arguments of the same nature I could use against consoles, but I don't because I see their lack of value in the discussion.
Some prefer console gaming (I did too for many years) and some prefer PC gaming and that's fine, we can't really "defeat" the other' preferences by imposing our own, especially with non-arguments and personal anecdotes on likes and dislikes.



Can all of you please stop with the derailing?

To the OP: Hope you don't regret it or rather hope you can enjoy pc gaming from now on (great platform).