Nah more like pathetic Xbots.  This guy whoever he is, is a moron.

So he's saying that it wouldn't sell as well because, without Nintendo's characters, it just wouldn't be fun or have the "big names" in it?

From what I've heard of the Final Fantasy games, they aren't always based around the same world or characters, so if Final Fantasy 13 wasn't called Final Fantasy, and instead something else, it too probably wouldn't sell as well. That's the nature of the industry. Big names (like Mario, FF, GTA, Sonic) sell games. I'd assume that if they did make the Smash Bros. games without Nintendo's characters, it probably would have sold decent, since any game has to start out as a unknown name game. And if they would have continued with it, then it could still be as big as it is today (though it would be big in a completely different way).

I didn't bother to read the whole thing, but I think overall he just likes hearing himself talk. It's his opinion of course, so one can't really say he's wrong. And if this is his opinion (and hell, it has to be), I'll take a quote from his own book "It's difficult to imagine that anyone would care." 

to funny

Joy, more of this opinion can not possibly be right or wrong crap.  If that was the case, everything would be subjective.  I really don't think you want to live in a world where nothing can have true value attributed to it.  Opinions can be wrong.  It's quite easy.  If I say I think I'm faster than Ty Lawson, that's my opinion, and it's wrong.  I like to look at it like this:

There is one set of absolute truths in the universe about everything.  However, humans rarely have enough information to decide whether or not something is completely true or false.  They can, however, determine whether an opinion is close to that absolute truth or which of two opinions is closer.  The latter is the case here.

ya well sales and played time shows most people with a wii disagree! I met a kid with a 360 and he said gaylo refering to how he felt about halo! so there may be a few ninty fans who agree but I doubt it! I got it for my kids they love unlocking the characters!

That's so obviously CrazzyMan talking! He just omitted the =) in the end.

Brawl is the best game ever that's the matter of fact
And some sucky opinion ain't gonna change that
:whistle:

Now that's an indisputable argument.

Bullshit. It is one persons opinion littered with misinformation labeled as facts. He puts forth things that are simply untrue as reality and builds an arguement off of it. The entire thing is extaordinairly painful to read because he never attempts to back-up any of his claims with anything resembling evidence.

Burn this review.