I'm not sure he understood the whole story himself from the first 5-10 minutes I watched.

Ditto

Plenty of Nintendo fans support third party games. We just choose to buy them for our Playstation or XBox. 

There's no special cookie that we get for buying a third party game on a Nintendo console, and the online communities for PS/XBox titles on many of these games are just much larger than the ones Nintendo brings to the table to boot that even if the port was a good one, it's just kinda like "what's the point?". 

The fact that Nintendo has made technically inferior consoles for the past decade and has pretty much ruled out feature parity in most multiplats anyway, and the Wii U came 5-6 years after the PS3/360, you can't realistically expect third parties to prioritize a system with a user base of 0 that primarily fixates on Mario games versus the PS/XBox userbases of 80 million each that are proven to buy third party games in large numbers. 

I certainly hope that's the case. If neither 3rd party support or Nintendo's own games can lead to great home console sales, they're going to be left betting on 'new' ideas. That, as we've seen, can be risky.

This is a perfectly valid stance. Hell, Wii U is my most used home console this gen and I love the games on it. However, it's not a well rounded lineup and will never attract a mass market to sustain it long term.

Every time someone tries to play the Nintendo fans give a free pass card I question if they're actually living in reality, Nintendo has the most critical fanbase out there. Want examples look at the Zelda cycle, look at the divide between Smash fans, look at the rift between Metroid fans and how OM has a mixed reaction, look at the constant calls for a 3D Mario game that's more like Galaxy, look at how Paper Mario on 3DS is hated or the angry reactions to DKTF being revealed.

Fact is Nintendo fans are even more critical then other fans it's just that the games for most part are still great to play and the's no free pass so when you get third parties who try to half ass things or aren't as consistent you're only going to see them get ripped to shreds by the fanbase. The reason third parties have issues on the platforms is because most of them only follow the mainstream while anyone who has a Nintendo platform is going to have a specific taste.

Yes, I understand that but that doesn't mean that it is alright for them to sell gimped versions of games on Nintendo platform + charge a premium and expect it to sell well... If they want a game to even have a chance of selling on the wiiU, they have to give the owners the full game with all the DLC cause if they don't, then they broke any legs that the game had from the start. Now I am not saying that the game will sell on the wiiU the same amount as any other console but when you are releasing a game that is inferior in every way other than graphics that directly effects the enjoyment of the overall game such as missing content, then they are riding the nonsense train.

I get why they don't want to prioritize the wiiU version but that doesn't mean that it is okay to sell a gimped version. If they don't want to give the full version, then don't bother releasing it at all cause no one in their right mind would actually pay for a gimped version when they can easily get a fully featured version on 5 other platforms. I expect them to either release a game that is fully featured or don't release one at all and not in the gray area of half assing it while charging a full price. And Nintendo fans have every right to bitch about it

What 3rd party games have been brought to the Wii U with proper support?

well b-tier 3rd party games would be nice. indies and nintendo alone lacks something sometimes. i would like another rayman.

or another final fantasy CC.

Owwww you didn't, ohhhhh you did.

So very clever in so many ways.