Forgot about MGSV, that'll be an major one for sure.

I can't narrow it down to five, but here's ten that I think will be considered (in no particular order):

Uncharted 4
The Legend of Zelda
Halo 5
Bloodborne
Xenoblade Chronicles X
The Witcher 3
Batman Arkham Knight
No Man's Sky
Hotline Miami 2
Metal Gear Solid V

There's probably more that I am missing, but 2015 has a lot of good games announced so far.

Splatoon................

Zelda, Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, The Witcher 3 and (or) The Phantom Pain / Batman AK / Halo 5.

Of course we can't say which one will be better, but I have a feeling that every award will pick a different winner. I mean, with high-quality games like that, it all comes to personal taste/opinions.

That said, I bet the winner of the major awards will be either Bloodborne or Zelda.

Top contenders-
Uncharted4
Zelda U
Witcher 3
MGS5
Halo5

With nominees being-
Batman
Bloodborne
Xenoblade (I hope)
No mans sky

Personally I think it will come down to Zelda vs Uncharted vs Witcher

Maybe it won't hit 90, but I still see Halo 5, MGSPP and Witcher 3 scoring higher than Evolve.  MGS for sure, if I had to pick right now my pick is MGS PP.  I mean MGS 4 was 94.  Higher than the last games in some of the series you listed like Uncharted 3, Dark Souls and Zelda SS.

Just naming games of the year shamelessly unreleased games makes this thread retarded. Im sorry. This is why most IPs have gone to hell. Cause they know releasing unfinished shit is already getting your vote as game of the year. This is whats wrong with modern and trendy fn "gamers"...

I think I speak for more people than just myself when I say "Thank you for ruining what should have been way more amazing if it wasnt for you". We could talk about this after we have played any of them though... maybe? :)

So many good looking games. I'll have trouble picking just one D:

I have a gut feeling that Evolve will do really well. We'll see. 

I'm talking more about media picks and not personal ones. Like who's going to win the most awards.