By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Did GameSpot go too far with this "Is It Time To Buy An Xbox One" video?

 

Is this a biased video?

Yes 93 31.21%
 
No 144 48.32%
 
Not Sure 18 6.04%
 
See results 43 14.43%
 
Total:298
KLXVER said:

I mean I dont have any knowledge of which developers are losing their jobs other than I do know that some of them are.  I also know that some of the console game developers are now seeing a bigger potential profit in making games on mobile devices.  

The other thing to note is that a lot of the great developers are also being snatched up by currently successful game developers like Naughty Dog.  I have also read articles where these game developers are creating new studios, which seem to be the indie developers nowadays.

The only thing that I can see Microsoft doing in the future is by winning over some of the indie developers that will make games exclusively for the XB1.  

 

There are news about companys cutting staff and development studios being closed down every other day. Irrational Games is an example. Grab these people before they form an indie company, makes a hit and you have to pay 2.5 billion dollars for them...

You are completely right.  I have absolutely no clue why Microsoft doesn't snatch up these studios before they close down.  Its a shame really to see people lose their jobs when the second richest company sits back and shells out 2.5 billion dollars on a game thats already out!

I am all for new and interesting games even though I wouldn't get the chance to play them since I game on Playstation consoles.  New games lead to new ideas and future ways of playing video games.  When I look at a stuido like Insomniac, with their new Sunset Overdrive game, I see a group of guys that sat down who wanted to make a fun, colorful, funny, and overall enjoyable game.  

THATS what gaming is all about.  Creating new experiences regardless of what gaming device it comes out on.  



Around the Network
d21lewis said:
Just watched all three. I'm not even sure if the people on that site even love video games......


Their work is gaming, not their passion.

If I´d have to play games 8 hours a day, and deal with every minor issue the consoles have I would probably be as duchy as those guys.

Game jornalism is losing more and more people that want to have fun. Even "indie" reviewes are getting over the top as analysis (Angry Joe).



We have known Gamespot has been very biased towards it for a while, specially Eddie. Talk about fause inofrmation and over-exaggerations, game journalists do it best and this video continues that trend.  And isnt it odd they make this video when Xbox One is selling well...

Anyways this comment explains it all

Paul Burns1 day ago

This is an example of what the Xbox One has had to deal with for the past year! gaming journalism at it's finest! i hope all Xbox One owners take notice! and those who are unbiased who watch this video! an absolute disgrace! and it's not just Gamespot doing it! from an Xbox One and PS4 owner! unsubsribing right now!




       

Its downright misinformative and bordering on the line of trolling and has no place being on a ''journalist'' website.

Those opinions were hardly subjective and the PS4 must have been mentioned the same amount of times and the xbox one.

No mention of the great games, no mention of the constant UI updates and upgrades. A dismal display of unprofessionalism.

1 Subscriber lost and I am sure many other have done the same.



foodfather said:
Its downright misinformative and bordering on the line of trolling and has no place being on a ''journalist'' website.

Those opinions were hardly subjective and the PS4 must have been mentioned the same amount of times and the xbox one.

No mention of the great games, no mention of the constant UI updates and upgrades. A dismal display of unprofessionalism.

1 Subscriber lost and I am sure many other have done the same.


I repeated that to mysey repeatedly during the video.  "These guys are journalists".  Journalists that can't even take the time to figure out an interface my little girl has mastered or figure out how to press the " menu " button on the controller to find...the menu.  It's their job to inform people and yet, they sound like clueless old people trying to program a VCR.

 

I have an Android phone.  My friend has an iPhone.  I don't like the interface because I never tried to figure it out.  I won't attack it.  I just know I need to spend more time with it.  I wonder what the outtakes were.  That video is like a professional assassination.  The others weren't much better but it's the worst of the lot.



Around the Network

Just with regards to Minecraft. It is extremely unlikely that MS bought MC to bolster their gaming devision. If anything they bought it to have the 50 million users on their portfolio.



KLXVER said:
Jimbo1337 said:
KLXVER said:

You specifically replied in the above post to this: "I mean how many XB1 owners are happy that MS bought that instead of investing all that money into new IPs or sequels to games many have been asking for?"

Why are you talking about whether it is a first party or third party developer?  I responded with exclusive titles that Microsoft has invested money into...

 

Their IPs. They are sitting on several beloved franchises and they decide to buy Minecraft instead of reviving those...

And how exactly do you want them to revive those other beloved franchises?  Stop producing Forza all together so they can make those games?


What? Is their gaming division really that small...?

Shame that $3billion could not go into increasing their development team. I mean who would choose 2 games exclusive marketing only, to 500 dev team across a few studios for a couple of years, making many exclusive games? It just dosent make sense.



It takes genuine talent to see greatness in yourself despite your absence of genuine talent.

eva01beserk said:

Shame that $3billion could not go into increasing their development team. I mean who would choose 2 games exclusive marketing only, to 500 dev team across a few studios for a couple of years, making many exclusive games? It just dosent make sense.


True and Minecraft is not even exclusive to MS consoles... Do they really think that Minecraft 2 will be a big hit? Really not sure where that franchise will go from here...



KLXVER said:
eva01beserk said:

Shame that $3billion could not go into increasing their development team. I mean who would choose 2 games exclusive marketing only, to 500 dev team across a few studios for a couple of years, making many exclusive games? It just dosent make sense.


True and Minecraft is not even exclusive to MS consoles... Do they really think that Minecraft 2 will be a big hit? Really not sure where that franchise will go from here...

Couldn't find the Phil Spencer interview where he was talking about prioritizing which games they want to develop, by using their 1st party studios, but here is a recent interview with phil spencer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27zQ71xiiBo

If you want to specifically listen to him talking about Minecraft, jump to 38:00



Mr Puggsly said:
Normchacho said:
I mean...I understand that these are just the opinions of the people there, and plenty of them are valid complaints, but why did Gamespot think this was a good idea to post?

How was this going to end in any other way than Xbox fans being pissed?

I was thinking the same thing. This is not a great way to appeal to the Xbox userbase and stuff like this certainly doesn't encourage MS to advertise on their site. What is the goal other than annoying some of thier readers/viewers?

More time was spent bitching about the interface than talking about games. They're out of touch.


Now, I don't think publications should be deciding what to send out based on what would piss off advertisers. That's sort of chicken shit, and I don't think them sharing there opinions is wrong either and I'm glad they didn't lie about it for the sake of keeping everyone happy. If they hate the interface then they should say that, I just hope they aren't surprised by the backlash.



Bet with Adamblaziken:

I bet that on launch the Nintendo Switch will have no built in in-game voice chat. He bets that it will. The winner gets six months of avatar control over the other user.