Just a confirmation that Nintendo is the king of making great games.

Diablo 3 reaper of souls is 8th gen and has a meta of more then 90... That game should be on the list!!!

I pointed that out as well, at the end of the 1st post :) Thats why at first i didnt add it, thats an arguably case though! I personally dont care, but for wat its worth it was a wiiu exclusive at one point

Why not year aligned?

I think Gears 4 (or w.e it will be called) will be the one to get it. Halo 5 seems to be changing a lot of things and I feel like many reviewers will be "butt-hurt" about it and it will be reflected in their review. Quantum Break will be a great game but Remedy, to my knowledge, has never made an excellent 90+ metacritic game.

They remind me of Sucker Punch from Sony's side. Always making great and fun games but none of their games reach that masterpiece status and I'm talking about the average score of the game, as I'm sure for many people games like Alan Wake have already reached that masterpiece status.

Slade6alpha said: @Tbone: Rayman should be removed since it's on 7th gen platforms... However... it was supposed to be on an 8th gen console first. Hmmm, your call

That one is arguably, im not against taking it off, maybe i should put it in its own section Lmao!

Super Mario 3D Land is the only game released within the timeframe of the xbox one and ps4's retail avaibaility that scored 90 or higher, the rest came out in the second and third year.

you can tell me that doesn't matter, in 2 years when the 90+ metacritic games are compared again, though I suspect "metacritic score means nothing" will be the excuse I hear then.

As if we needed any confirmation =P

I made a thread for that, well 2014 top rated games over 85+

Is that new for this gen though? I thought it was originally a ps3 game years ago? (correct me if im wrong)