By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Physical for digital trade in program?

Ka-pi96 said:
Don't think it would be worth setting up. Just sounds like a complicated and possible costly venture that not many people would really use.


The easiest answer is to setup up a program at Sony/Microsoft stores where you bring it in and they shred it on the spot and issue you the code.  No real cost besides some time.  That also gives them a chance to bump you into more product while in the store.  

I know there aren't many M$ or Sony stores, so they could also work a deal with Target or Bestbuy or something to offer the same thing.  



It is near the end of the end....

Around the Network
Sentient_Nebula said:

That seems like an interesting idea. Besides, Sony and MS want you to buy games digitally (More DRM, no second-hand market, more profits). So the more people they can get off discs, the happier they'll be.

I would always prefer disc though. It costs the same as digital, and I have more freedom with the game (I could lend it to a friend, or sell it used). Discs also save on storage space. Having to change discs for games isn't that big a deal for me.

The only way to convince me to go all-digital is if the digital games cost less than their disc-based counterparts.


I recognize the appeal of physical copies ...I still have a huge Sega Genesis/Sega CD collection that I wouldn't trade for the world, despite the fact I can play all those games on dozen different emulators. 

The thing is that the new consoles just work better when everything is digital.  The whole pause/resume feature is downright broken when multiple disk games are involved. Call me lazy but I hate swapping those disks...and even seeing them stacked in the living room bugs me.

I recieved Dead Rising 3 few weeks ago on disk. The game has a 16 GB patch after initial iisk install...Halo MCC is something like 20 GB patch on day 1. The physical disks for these games is downright useless by themselves and serve just as a showpiece in the living room while DLC is the actual game. 

If I could go visit friends for a night and bring my disk games with me to play right away, I would see a purpose for them. But they sometimes take up to an hour to install and if the game has additional DLC that has to be installed, forget about playing it at all that night. 



disolitude said:
Sentient_Nebula said:

That seems like an interesting idea. Besides, Sony and MS want you to buy games digitally (More DRM, no second-hand market, more profits). So the more people they can get off discs, the happier they'll be.

I would always prefer disc though. It costs the same as digital, and I have more freedom with the game (I could lend it to a friend, or sell it used). Discs also save on storage space. Having to change discs for games isn't that big a deal for me.

The only way to convince me to go all-digital is if the digital games cost less than their disc-based counterparts.


I recognize the appeal of physical copies ...I still have a huge Sega Genesis/Sega CD collection that I wouldn't trade for the world, despite the fact I can play all those games on dozen different emulators. 

The thing is that the new consoles just work better when everything is digital.  The whole pause/resume feature is downright broken when multiple disk games are involved. Call me lazy but I hate swapping those disks...and even seeing them stacked in the living room bugs me.

I recieved Dead Rising 3 few weeks ago on disk. The game has a 16 GB patch after initial iisk install...Halo MCC is something like 20 GB patch on day 1. The physical disks for these games is downright useless by themselves and serve just as a showpiece in the living room while DLC is the actual game. 

If I could go visit friends for a night and bring my disk games with me to play right away, I would see a purpose for them. But they sometimes take up to an hour to install and if the game has additional DLC that has to be installed, forget about playing it at all that night. 

I choose discs for long term investment. Unless the companies can provide my DL's will work on my PS3 in 30 years. PSN being shutdown etc. Like my NES does, for example. Cause that HDD is gonna fail long before the system hardware does. And I'd just fix it. HDD data, not so much. Well, intill the PS3 OS is fully hacked. And I can backup the drive at will.



It would be great but probably to expensive for MS/Sony. I would much rather you got a digital alternative when buying the game, when you download it digitally, the game disc becomes unusable. This would require a one-time, online check-up for every game but I think people can manage :).

Btw, I am the only one buying my games here, all digital :).