You´re talking about the games and not the characters, right? 

 Because in that case, between these two, I would go with Toad. But I think you should have included Yoshi's New Island in there. In that scenario I would have gone with Yoshi.

Now if you´re talking about the characters...   Nahh I would go with Toad anyway.

Sackboy is ugly. Just makes me itchy to look at it. Some of the other characters are downright creepy.
Toad is adorable. From the look to the movement to the music to the voice.

the sack/beanie itself isnt the cutest thing,but the overall world is very cute/adorable... but if you include the trillion different skins/outfits to dress sack up in,you'd have a dif story,who actually plays as a naked sack?theres a number of cute ones, the free statue of liberty sack outfit thats on the psn is as cute as heck http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2515/3682102004_4cb29b2536_o.jpg

tht is fucking adorbes!

Toad just pretends to be cute because chicks dig it. He's a real pussy hound, actually. You should see him in the gym. Motherfucker benches like 400 lbs.

Sackboy? Wishes he had Toad's swagger.

eventually he will get tired of videogames at least my kid did now he only wants to play football/fussball. last time he played videogames was 2 or 3 days ago for about 10-15 minutes then he turned it off and that was a shock for me he almost never does that...I can still hear my wife screaming when she saw what our son was playing

I don't know, something about sackboy creeps me out. Maybe its that live-action commercial...

I'm going to vote for Captain Falcon.

Alright everybody lets divide up along the obvious party lines and have a good time feuding about who's da kyootest!

Captain Toad!