Ah well if it's spike then I can see Titanfall or COD winning it then :p

2015 or 2016

Game if the year candidates?

Mario Kart 8
Smas Bros
Bayonetta 2

This ''fight'' ended before it could even start

why nobody considers SMASH BROS?!

Dark souls 2 ?

Mario Galaxy was an exception if I'm not mistaken!

I do.

Evem though the original Bayonetta is my favorite action game ever, I really don't think Bayonetta 2 has a shot at being got, because it's somewhat a divisive title, and we no longer have that wow factor.

I was leaning towards WatchDogs or Destiny, before they came out, they are indeed good games, but won't be GOTY.... 

This year is in dark, personally the best game for me was MK8, the damm MK8 which wasn't even that high reviewed, but it still the best so far.... Smash for me will have a shot.

But if Smash, MK8 or Destiny ends up with GOTY, it is solely because of lack heavy competition. If Mario Galaxy, Uncharted, Legend of Zelda, Metroid, Journey, Arkham Asylum, Last of Us, Halo, GTA game that always face heavy competition in its release years were launched this year, they would have been easily GOTY.

Just Imagine, if Mario 3D World or Last of Us or GTA or Bioshock have been launched this year, who would take a GOTY from them?

Smash Bros U also has a chance now.

WatchDogs's GOTY. It's a new IP, it's a new type of gameplay, it's long & varied and the gameplay is quite rich & challenging.

My personal GOTY is still Child of Light though...

What is DA:I btw?