Retro. Metroid Prime.

Its rare but it happens. It also happens that a dev can start mediocre and turn to completely shit in short order.

The IP was, sure, but the game was nothing like its predecessors. But I get your point.

Either way, I don't like giving devs arbitrary "they'll do better", we can't really say. We will have to wait and see if the pre-release opinions will match the released product of the Order. If they do... I won't expect much else from these devs with any sort of "hype".

i will probably just either wait for the reviews or a for a 30 dollar price price drop cause this looks like a last gen shooter with a current gen coat of pain

This ^^

This is just one reviewer with a negative perpective.

 i wil be waiting for the game to come out and get a true review. 

Yep, and here's another preview that actually... you know, previews the game.

http://www.gamereactor.eu/previews/201584/E3+Selection+-+The+Order%3A+1886/

Interesting quote: "During the demo we were shown alternative outcomes to those set pieces we saw during the press conference - the idea being to show us it's not really quick time events, but actually something a bit more dynamic and quite frankly, very appetising."

Ooooh Marty Sliva. I like him on IGN's podcasts but I can't stand his reviews and previews.

This is the guy who legit wrote an article complaining about Nintendo's Splatoon not being a mascot platformer. I'm dead serious .

Nintendo was giving one of their well known franchises to a western dev that never made a game. Though Nitnendos involment di d play a big role in the development process, what Retro was doing was not something easy. Trying to transistion a game from 2D to 3D while still trying to keep most of the major elements can end horribly. Especially if you are going from 2D side scroller to FPS.

I feel that this writer is complaining more about the lack of new content from The Order rather than the game itself. The PAX demo is the same demo from Gamescom and many gamers were safisfied with how it played out. So, now it begs the question, what has this guy been doing over the past 3 weeks?

Not only that, he has very little understanding as to how the thermite gun works. Here's his comment on the gun:

"The problem here was that the bullets spread out in such a wide area so quickly, that I could burst-fire an entire clip at an enemy across a street and have every single bullet miss its target."

The goal with the thermite gun is NOT to hit your enemies with the thermite bullets. The point of spreading them out is so you can have a larger blast range to deal damage to more enemies at once.

Most people that bought ZombiU knew that the gameplay was going to be limited due to it's survival horrorness, it got flack for having the same difficulty throughout the game, never gradually upping up the difficulty or challenging the player. After playing for and hour or so, the player has pretty much played everything the game has to offer. Multiplayer was cool, asymmetrical gameplay like evolve

With thanks to the OP for choosing to bring us a negative review, I guess I'll just choose to accept more positive ones.

I have made up my mind to buy the game a long time ago anyway.