By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Halo 5 vs. Uncharted 4 vs. Zelda U - Reality check necrobump!

People guesses on Halo are too low Imo. Depending on how good the multiplayer it can easily sell over 10M.



Around the Network
Xevross said:

Uncharted: 98 metacritic  FW: 2.4m  Lifetime: 8.2m (I know I'm optimistic )

Halo 5: 91 metacritic FW: 2.7m   Lifetime: 7.1m

Zelda: 92 metacritic  FW: 1.1m   Lifetime: 4.2m

98 on Metacritic?! That would be even more than the legendary Uncharted 2! O.O



                
       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

GhetooBillGates said:
Xevross said:

Uncharted: 98 metacritic  FW: 2.4m  Lifetime: 8.2m (I know I'm optimistic )

Halo 5: 91 metacritic FW: 2.7m   Lifetime: 7.1m

Zelda: 92 metacritic  FW: 1.1m   Lifetime: 4.2m

Damn Uncharted 4 98 That would be the best Rated Naughty Dog game ever, for your sake i hope it does, but troll reviewers will prevent that from happening. 

Its more of hope and a bit of a dream really. Realistically I think 96 but it certainly can be one of the best games ever so 98 isn't out of the question.



AZWification said:
Xevross said:

Uncharted: 98 metacritic  FW: 2.4m  Lifetime: 8.2m (I know I'm optimistic )

Halo 5: 91 metacritic FW: 2.7m   Lifetime: 7.1m

Zelda: 92 metacritic  FW: 1.1m   Lifetime: 4.2m

98 on Metacritic?! That would be even more than the legendary Uncharted 2! O.O

And I hope it will be even more legendary.



My predictions:

UC4 will sell more than Halo 5 which will sell more than Zelda.

In terms of Metacritic it'll be Zelda > UC4 >> Halo 5.



Around the Network
Name Metacritic First Week Lifetime
Halo 5 90 2.500.000 8.000.000
Uncharted 4 95 2.000.000 7.000.000
Zelda U 94 1.300.000 4.700.000



Sigs are dumb. And so are you!

Name Metacritic First Week Lifetime
Halo 5 87-92% 2,750,000+ 8,500,000+
Uncharted 4 90-95% 1,750,000+ 6,500,000+
Zelda U 89-94% 1,100,000+ 3,750,000+

I guess their sales also depend on the amount & how long they'reTHE bundled games for, I'm guessing all three games will release Q4 2015, perfect time for some huge holiday bundling.

I'm really looking forward to UC4, first time I'm atually hyped for an UC game. After TLoU I have complete faith in ND to create another amazing experience.



Considering that 343i is no bungie, I very much doubt that the next Halo will be anything gamers consider decent. I expect a metacritic score of 80-85. It's real value is 70-75, but we must also take into account Microsoft bribery which will influence a few scores.

Also, I doubt Halo 5 will sell above 5 million, since the core gamers have abandoned the Xbox platform.
Uncharted 4 numbers are within range.

Edit - Moderated - Starcraft



Why are people expecting Uncharted to grow that much?



cpg716 said:
Raziel123 said:
thx1139 said:
Seriously?

Halo 4 9+ million
Uncharted 3 6+ million
Zelda TP 6+ million on a console that sold over 100 million

With that in mind
Halo 5 9+ million
Uncharted 4 6+ million
Zelda Wii U 2-3 million


You're neglecting to take into account the ~10 million bigger install base on PS4 compared to xb1

He is neglecting to take into an account a number you just made up in your head??

The gap right now is less then 4 million and likely won't be increasing much over the next 6 months..    $399 price cut in June..  September marks the releases of 20 or so more markets..   Novermber is Halo: MCC..   Plus big titles of COD, Battlefield,  Fable and Sunset Overdrive. While the PS4 will maintain a healthy lead.. I dont think it will widen to 10 million within the next year. 

but ps4 is supposed to take off and eventually break 200m consoles!