1. Yes, we've barely seen any of the game.
2. They'll probably have equal hype.

There is no way a game you can rent and beat over the weekend is going to outsell Halo.

I know a LOT of friends who are not even upgrading until the new Halo is out, many of them have said Halo 2 MP on XBO may make them get a new console.

There are more die hard Halo fans than you even know. 

You can rent and beat Halo in a day, and before you say multiplayer, Uncharted has it also.  May not be as fleshed out as Halo's, but it's certainly there.

and nowhere near as popular.

343 wants Halo back on the MLG circuit which is good for the fans.  Less CoD elements, more Halo. 

1. Yes, they're a huge deal. We only know they exist, there's so much more to find out about them.

2. I'd say they cancel out. Critical Reception and sales are bound to be very similar.

I've thought f the Uncharted series as trash, but considering UC4 will probably have an open world instead of corridors i may be more hyped for it :p.
I haven't bought Halo 4 honestly, and idk if i'll pick up H5. I only played 1 and 3, but I remember loving them both to death :D

Halo is the bigger franchise. Sales prove this. The only way Uncharted would be able to eclipse/cancel Halo out is if the graphics are top, top notch and gameplay is shown. Of course to me though Uncharted is more important than any Halo so it would eclipse halo for me.


As always though its going to be a surprise announcement or sheer depth of content that "wins" e3

Also a Grran Turismo 7 announcement with an epic trailer would trump both :D

What a stupid thread.

They cancel each other out unless one shows significantly better content than the other.