By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - E3: Halo 5 vs Uncharted 4 question

GhetooBillGates on 04 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:
FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

Well that's just like, your opinion man.

IMO this E3 wont matter much for both, 2015 will be when the big guns come out.

Considering the critical acclaim that TLOU received, it's not just his opinion.


So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTA V didnt score as many GOTYS did it, nor did it score any awards at the Annies which rarely give awards to videogames.  The Last Of Us did all that without having being an estabilished franchise.



Around the Network
DerNebel on 04 June 2014

They'll cancel each other out imo.

I'll rate E3s on surprises and on how much of the shown stuff will actually be out before next years E3, so games that we already know about, that won't be out before holiday 2015, don't give many points in my book.



mornelithe on 04 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.



FATALITY on 04 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:
FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

Well that's just like, your opinion man.

IMO this E3 wont matter much for both, 2015 will be when the big guns come out.

Considering the critical acclaim that TLOU received, it's not just his opinion.


So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 


and do u have any idea how many awards TLOU won?



”The environment where PlayStation wins is best for this industry” (Jack Tretton, 2009)

torok on 04 June 2014
sales2099 said:

1. Would either one count as a major point in the conferences since we already know of their existence?

2. If both are shown, in terms of deciding who "won" E3,  do they cancel out or will one be elevated over the other?


1. If they show gameplay and/or story details yes. If they just tease them, no.

2. Cancel out. They are from different genres, so I don't think they are much comparable, except for visuals.



Bet with jetforcejiminy: PS4 will pass the Wii lifetime numbers.

Around the Network
sales2099 on 04 June 2014
FATALITY said:
sales2099 said:
FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

See I wonder since my estimation of online communities there are 8 Sony fans out of every 10 average users. Now since they will side with Sony no matter what, would Uncharted be considered the winner by default since its maker is really respected?

Because I can easily counter that Halo is a much bigger IP with a larger focus on MP and a sizeable following in its lore. 

halo was a big i.p cuz bungie was behind it and lets not forget that fps was the most popular genre in US where xb360 pretty much killed ps3.

both games are a year off lets wait and see

Last I checked Halo 4 sold 9 million copies. Im just saying that saying Uncharted wins because LOU and Naughty Dog are awesome doesn't elevate the Uncharted IP over Halo.

If Uncharted wins over Halo, it would be because they show gameplay and MS shows a CGI trailer. That would make sense to say Uncharted made more of a impact. But yes, wait and see.  



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

jlmurph2 on 04 June 2014
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.

My point is that it IS an opinion. Hes saying it's a fact. Yes its true that TLOU has awards but that doesn't mean Naughty Dog > all MS Studios is a fact.



WolfpackN64 on 04 June 2014

I think it is, Halo just is a bigger franchise than Uncharted, not that Uncharted is bad, but just saying.



GhetooBillGates on 04 June 2014

@sales i respect your opinion stated above but I feel Uncharted 4 could be the ultimate winner with a curtain call, ND have the skill to pull it off easily kinda of like they did with TLOU, HALO 5 could try somethig similar, but its already been at E3 so it loses some of its luster and wont really surprise anyone, we will see wont we.



zumnupy10 on 04 June 2014

UC4 will have the bigger impact at E3 between these two games.  ND left Playstation fans very hyped to see what UC4 can be after TLoU.

Opinions on Halo made by 343i weren't so unanimous.  Fans seem to me more worried than hyped.

I see many people in this thread who think that the amount of sales that each game can achieve, defines which one is more impactant.   If that was true, this thread wouldn't even be necessary, since we already know which game is going to sell more.