E3: Halo 5 vs Uncharted 4 question

[sales2099]

FATALITY said:

sales2099 said:

FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

See I wonder since my estimation of online communities there are 8 Sony fans out of every 10 average users. Now since they will side with Sony no matter what, would Uncharted be considered the winner by default since its maker is really respected?

Because I can easily counter that Halo is a much bigger IP with a larger focus on MP and a sizeable following in its lore. 

halo was a big i.p cuz bungie was behind it and lets not forget that fps was the most popular genre in US where xb360 pretty much killed ps3.

both games are a year off lets wait and see

Last I checked Halo 4 sold 9 million copies. Im just saying that saying Uncharted wins because LOU and Naughty Dog are awesome doesn't elevate the Uncharted IP over Halo.

If Uncharted wins over Halo, it would be because they show gameplay and MS shows a CGI trailer. That would make sense to say Uncharted made more of a impact. But yes, wait and see.