By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - E3: Halo 5 vs Uncharted 4 question

mornelithe on 04 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.

My point is that it IS an opinion. Hes saying it's a fact. Yes its true that TLOU has awards but that doesn't mean Naughty Dog > all MS Studios is a fact.

Yes, I'm very happy that you're able to identify what an opinion is.  However, I don't care, nor did I say it wasn't an 'opinion'.  You sait it was 'Your opinion', and I said it isn't just HIS opinion, a great many people in the gaming world share his opinion, and the awards Naughty Dog has received kinda exemplify that point.  Beyond that, I really, really don't care.



Around the Network
Mr Khan on 04 June 2014
FATALITY said:
jlmurph2 said:
FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

Well that's just like, your opinion man.

IMO this E3 wont matter much for both, 2015 will be when the big guns come out.


lets be real here

its not my opinion

It is an opinion. So i have declared.

Now stop this moronic line of debate.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

GhetooBillGates on 04 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.

My point is that it IS an opinion. Hes saying it's a fact. Yes its true that TLOU has awards but that doesn't mean Naughty Dog > all MS Studios is a fact.

ND > all Ms studios is in fact true ND > all Sony Studios is fact aswell, Nintendo EAD is the only competition i see for ND, until another studio comes out with three consecutive games that score GOTYS in the 200-300's with 96+ metacritc range than we can change that fact.  



jlmurph2 on 04 June 2014
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.

My point is that it IS an opinion. Hes saying it's a fact. Yes its true that TLOU has awards but that doesn't mean Naughty Dog > all MS Studios is a fact.

Yes, I'm very happy that you're able to identify what an opinion is.  However, I don't care, nor did I say it wasn't an 'opinion'.  You sait it was 'Your opinion', and I said it isn't just HIS opinion, a great many people in the gaming world share his opinion, and the awards Naughty Dog has received kinda exemplify that point.  Beyond that, I really, really don't care.


...you do know what I said to him is just an internet phrase/meme? You took it too literal when I said "Well that's just like, your opinion man"



jlmurph2 on 04 June 2014
Mr Khan said:
FATALITY said:
jlmurph2 said:
FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

Well that's just like, your opinion man.

IMO this E3 wont matter much for both, 2015 will be when the big guns come out.


lets be real here

its not my opinion

It is an opinion. So i have declared.

Now stop this moronic line of debate.


No problem



Around the Network
sales2099 on 04 June 2014
GhetooBillGates said:
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.

My point is that it IS an opinion. Hes saying it's a fact. Yes its true that TLOU has awards but that doesn't mean Naughty Dog > all MS Studios is a fact.

ND > all Ms studios is in fact true ND > all Sony Studios is fact aswell, Nintendo EAD is the only competition i see for ND, until another studio comes out with three consecutive games that score GOTYS in the 200-300's with 96+ metacritc range than we can change that fact.  

We are aware that the studio has a great track record. But that doesn't mean Uncharted is bigger then Halo.



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

mornelithe on 04 June 2014
jlmurph2 said:

...you do know what I said to him is just an internet phrase/meme? You took it too literal when I said "Well that's just like, your opinion man"

I'm just an old caveman gamer, your internet meme's frighten and confuse me.  But no, I wasn't aware of the meme, and I wasn't trying to be a dick either, I was just saying that both franchises have their accolades.  And, if we just go by sales, yes, Halo will murder Uncharted, but, as far as E3 jaw droppers go, who knows?  TLOU made people go crazy when it was revealed, and with that team now working on UC...who the hell knows what happens with the series.



FATALITY on 04 June 2014
Mr Khan said:
FATALITY said:
jlmurph2 said:
FATALITY said:

naughty dog>>>>>>>>>every MS studios

so Uncharted wins by default

Well that's just like, your opinion man.

IMO this E3 wont matter much for both, 2015 will be when the big guns come out.


lets be real here

its not my opinion

It is an opinion. So i have declared.

Now stop this moronic line of debate.

so ND won the studio of the year doesnt mean anything



”The environment where PlayStation wins is best for this industry” (Jack Tretton, 2009)

GhetooBillGates on 04 June 2014
sales2099 said:
GhetooBillGates said:
jlmurph2 said:
mornelithe said:
jlmurph2 said:

So you're admitting that GTA V is better than TLOU because of critical acclaim? 

GTAV isn't currently the all-time awards winner, TLOU is.  I was merely pointing out that it wasn't just his opinion, many many people viewed Naughty Dogs work with TLOU as higher quality than...well, any other game ever.  Again, not saying UC4 is going to sell more, not saying Halo's going to bomb.  Just saying, his opinion is backed up by quite a few people, as is Halo being a big seller, by historical numbers.

My point is that it IS an opinion. Hes saying it's a fact. Yes its true that TLOU has awards but that doesn't mean Naughty Dog > all MS Studios is a fact.

ND > all Ms studios is in fact true ND > all Sony Studios is fact aswell, Nintendo EAD is the only competition i see for ND, until another studio comes out with three consecutive games that score GOTYS in the 200-300's with 96+ metacritc range than we can change that fact.  

We are aware that the studio has a great track record. But that doesn't mean Uncharted is bigger then Halo.

Yep i Agree HALO is a bigger franchise, even without bungie at the Helm, 343i is a very capable team. My comment was just to reflect on the statement that was mentioned in the quote tree. I am very excited for HALO 5 guardians including the rumored Anniversary collection with all the games.



RenCutypoison on 04 June 2014

New Gen = new IP IMO

Sequels will not decide who wins E3