By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Who feels Pokemon XY can beat GTA V sells numbers in the first week. [PART 2]

 

Who feels Pokemon XY can beat GTA V sells numbers in the first week.

Yes 32 40.00%
 
No 25 31.25%
 
See Results 20 25.00%
 
Total:77

You cant compare the preorder figures between the two. BW released on an established install base. 3DS's is still growing.  3DS sales will spike once XY hit.



Around the Network
Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
SonOfLiberty said:
Lawlight said:
Pokemon lifetime sales won't even beat GTAV's first week of sales.

no pokemon has sold that low


Black & White?



undertracked here, it sold almost 16mil, but XY will be bigger!

GTAV's first week is 17.5M anyway.

Edit: And funny you say that - X/Y preorder numbers are 35% that of B&W.



that doesn't mean crap lol, 50mil DS users vs 10mil 3DS users, XY will sell more than BW. Look at COMG for instance,points are worse for XY but japan has just got 1mil pre orders already!

SonOfLiberty said:

You cant compare the preorder figures between the two. BW released on an established install base. 3DS's is still growing.  3DS sales will spike once XY hit.



even crazier when holiday and nintendo promotes the 2DS heavy

tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
SonOfLiberty said:
Lawlight said:
Pokemon lifetime sales won't even beat GTAV's first week of sales.

no pokemon has sold that low


Black & White?



undertracked here, it sold almost 16mil, but XY will be bigger!

GTAV's first week is 17.5M anyway.

Edit: And funny you say that - X/Y preorder numbers are 35% that of B&W.



that doesn't mean crap lol, 50mil DS users vs 10mil 3DS users, XY will sell more than BW. Look at COMG for instance,points are worse for XY but japan has just got 1mil pre orders already!


What's COMG? Also, your install base theory doesn't explain why B&W2 solds so little despite having close to 3 times the install base when B&W came out.



SonOfLiberty said:
menx64 said:
In an ideal world it should... not happening though... Lifetime maybe... GTA is even more casual than pokemon.


Pokemon is surprisingly competitive online. alot harder than most games. its in the fighting game tier in terms of competitive play difficulty

So true... People get really surprised when they find out is no joke.

 For those you do not know:



Menx64

3DS code: 1289-8222-7215

NNid: Menx064

Around the Network
tbone51 said:
SonOfLiberty said:

You cant compare the preorder figures between the two. BW released on an established install base. 3DS's is still growing.  3DS sales will spike once XY hit.



even crazier when holiday and nintendo promotes the 2DS heavy

completely forgot about the 2DS. it was made for parents to cheap out and get their kids a handheld capable of playing pokemon. 2DS+pokemon is cheaper than XL



Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
SonOfLiberty said:
Lawlight said:
Pokemon lifetime sales won't even beat GTAV's first week of sales.

no pokemon has sold that low


Black & White?



undertracked here, it sold almost 16mil, but XY will be bigger!

GTAV's first week is 17.5M anyway.

Edit: And funny you say that - X/Y preorder numbers are 35% that of B&W.



that doesn't mean crap lol, 50mil DS users vs 10mil 3DS users, XY will sell more than BW. Look at COMG for instance,points are worse for XY but japan has just got 1mil pre orders already!


What's COMG? Also, your install base theory doesn't explain why B&W2 solds so little despite having close to 3 times the install base when B&W came out.

you dont understand how pokemon works. B2&W2 arent sequels, theyre the same game with extra content. The games are a part of the same gen. no graphical or gameplay changes.A sequel is Red to Gold, not Red to Yellow. 7m fow what basically is a GOTY version is amazing,  not a disappointment 



Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
tbone51 said:
Lawlight said:
SonOfLiberty said:
Lawlight said:
Pokemon lifetime sales won't even beat GTAV's first week of sales.

no pokemon has sold that low


Black & White?



undertracked here, it sold almost 16mil, but XY will be bigger!

GTAV's first week is 17.5M anyway.

Edit: And funny you say that - X/Y preorder numbers are 35% that of B&W.



that doesn't mean crap lol, 50mil DS users vs 10mil 3DS users, XY will sell more than BW. Look at COMG for instance,points are worse for XY but japan has just got 1mil pre orders already!


What's COMG? Also, your install base theory doesn't explain why B&W2 solds so little despite having close to 3 times the install base when B&W came out.



ok, i see now. You dont understand about pokemon third installments. Every gen has a new game that comes out which is a director's cut in them. some of them are different(adding story/new moves/more feat/etc). People who dont play pokemon get confused with BW2. Its not a new gen game. Its a third installment. Its been out for a year and sold almost 7mil, making it the 3rd highest selling director cut game. It beat Emerald/Crstal which sold 6.39mil/6.41mil lifetime. Its going to outsell the 2nd highest (platinum) lifetime as well whicch i think it currently has 7.6mil. BW2 isnt a main game, pls dont compare its sales with the Big 6 gen games. Totally Different



menx64 said:
SonOfLiberty said:
menx64 said:
In an ideal world it should... not happening though... Lifetime maybe... GTA is even more casual than pokemon.


Pokemon is surprisingly competitive online. alot harder than most games. its in the fighting game tier in terms of competitive play difficulty

So true... People get really surprised when they find out is no joke.

 For those you do not know:



i didn't start doing competitive intill 4th gen. People think pokemon is kiddy, but most people dont understand is you need to be smart *** ****! Its a mental/guessing/competive game. And to work for 1 pokemon can take days/even weeks O.o

SonOfLiberty said:

you dont understand how pokemon works. B2&W2 arent sequels, theyre the same game with extra content. The games are a part of the same gen. no graphical or gameplay changes.A sequel is Red to Gold, not Red to Yellow. 


So, what's your logic for thinking that Pokemon will be bigger than the DS ones when all signs point to the contrary?

I personally can't wait for the first weeks sales to be out. It will be hilarious.