The moment the three combines perfectly. I call that the "glimax"

I voted story but most accurate is Story + Gameplay. Based on the first games that came to mind under memorable, Final Fantasy VI, Ocarina of Time and Escape from Monkey Island.

I'll go with the story. If it's good, I'll prob remember it over the others.

Story for me.

gameplay or story depends on the game. I am pretty sure everyone remembers Super Mario Bros or Tetris and both games have either no or almost no story.

Graphics are totally unimportant because the brain is fooling one in thinking the game looked better than it actually did.

No games will be excellent if it's 10/10 in one area 1/10 everwhere else.

Although I think gameplay while being well balanced is needed first and foremost, then atleast a good story and good graphics.

Gameplay. I'll remember Final Fantasy VIII forever thanks to it.

Graphics, though I'll be more specific and say "visuals." They aren't what make a game great, but they are what make a game memorable.

I would say most of the time it is gameplay or story, depending on the genre.