I guess your right about it. I didn't rememeber whether he hated it or just didn't want it to be adapted, but now that you said it, I guess that was it. Well, I went on to see it, since I enjoy the Novel and I had also enjoyed 300 from the same movie director. But he has made a horrible cast choice and gave much emphasis to action scenes, which were also horrible. But i got to say the script solution to the alien monster thing got better off with using Dr. Manhattan, really, if I can think of anything positive about the movie.

I can give you that. The movie had style over substance, which was a mistake. But I don't know, man. I liked the adaptation. It seemed impossible, but they managed to mash-up the whole Watchmen in two hours and a half.

I hear ya loud and clear, and that was something the Graphic Novel was NOT about, at all. But I could be ok if the style were at least good, but I thought it to be much too over the top for my taste (it was fine for 300, for instance, but that movie did not really take itself too seriously, which is usually a positive issue). The actor portraying Rorschach was good though, and went on to make a nice appearance on Shutter Island by Scorcese.

Anyway, back to our talk, it's not that it is a bad movie, but it could have been so much better. Maybe if they had Sam Raimi do it?