The comic books never really covered his childhood much...it's like the gap between batman age 8 & adult, before someone in 1987 created the origins of Batman's skills.
Superman never was cocky nor full of himself like Thor, so either way that's just asking to go agianst the superman comics.
Ok. So how about do neither and make him calm, collected, mild mannered, relentlessly moral, and always doing the right thing like he was in the comics?
Plus Superman was full of confidence when he dawn on the suit, but as a kid he was just a kid who just wanted frieñds and to have fun, like any other kid.
And there's really no reason he couldn't make a lot of friends. With muscles like that and super powers he should have been a pussy magnet.
Spoilers from here on out:
Being a loner was just him trying to find out what he should do with his life when he has all these unique abilities, plus he had just let his father die just so he could just find the right way to reveal what he can do to the world someday, so he is not just going to screw over what Jonathan Kent died for.
But Superman never truly grappled with that. He's always been portrayed as innately good and moral. He never required humanity to prove themselve worthy of his salvation.
Even in Smallville (series), superman struggles with X-Ray & hearing and so fort, so it is not even a new concept to superman.
Superman is a rookie and has never been a hero outside of saving kids from a easy school bus to just push out of the water. It's hard to fight bad guys with such great power to equal your own when you have never fought in your life...he's from a farm and doesn't know what to do in such a situation, and he does try to minimize the damage in the small town but has no experience and is doing the best he can with no clue on how to even begin to try to handle the situation.....he's a rookie and is just trying to the best of his abili, when he doesn't even really have a grasp on his powers to do full force....this is e weakest suited superman I have ever seen, but he has no clue of just how strong he has become growing on earth.
There is a difference between not being very good and not caring. If Superman coouldn't save everyone, that's not necessarily a bad thing, and it could be presented as a part of the growing process for him. HOwever, he just repeatedly rams through buildings and wrecks shit. And how hard is it to think "Gee golly maybe I shouldn't fight in a crowded city". It's not rocket science.
The black hole didn't kill anyone, they where just sent to another dimension.
The planet engine (or whatever it was called) had to have killed thousands and thousands of people. There is no way Superman's fight with the kryptonians didn't kill more. An insurance firm did an analysis of the damage that would have been done in the fight. It comes out to over 100,000 dead and about 5 trillion in damages
Superman has super sight and hearing and X-Ray, so he knows where he threw the Villians. Remember, he grew up his whole life with these abilities.
You just said that he's a rookie and therefore was a bit careless. So, he's too much of a rookie to get the villains away from the city, but he's not too much of a rookie to know the exact trajectory each Kryptonian will take when punched, and plot a course that will prevent them from hitting anyone, causing debris to fall on someone, or otherwise injuring maiming or damaging people? Come on.
And again, after all of the death that happened Superman just sits there making out with Lois. Not a care in the world about the devastated city, the thousands buried in the rubble. And why exactly would the world love him for this? What did he do besides defeat people that would never ever had come to Earth if not for him? They would have been much better off if Superman had never come to Earth.
So why exactly are we supposed to cheer for Superman? Because he beat the three aliens that he drew to the planet, and only let about 100,000 people die in the process which millions lost everything they had? The only "heroic" think Superman did was decide not to commit genocide, and honestly, that's a decision I think most of us would have made.
1): Jonathan Kent said he maybe should have let them die, but then he said that he did the right thing though.
The fact that he even suggested letting the kids die is not only completely out of character, but despicable.
2): lois was on the ship, because since Superman activated the beacon' that meant that he could have learn how to not be successfully probed by Kryptonians, plus the useful knowledge they got from Lois was the exact same useful knowledge they got from superman, so if superman had learned how to not be probe by his biological father or something else on the ship, then they still would have gotten the same useful knowledge that later turned out to be 100% useless. But thanks to the blood sample they learned that every cell in his body was of an entire kryptonian's blood.
They seemed to have absolutely no problem probing him. The probing system is presumably designed for Kryptonians, so there is no reason that a Kryptonian with no special training should be able to resist it. Plus, the Kryptonians like JUST got there. Unless I missed something, I'm not sure how they even knew what his relationship with Lois Lane was.
3): he clearly knew that his people didn't care about where his mom lived, because why would his advance race care about an earthling, when they are clearly there for a reason that either has to do with his space ship or the one he found or the key with the S or something else that might have something to do with his biological father or something else Kryptonians, especially when they where only asking for him.
Uhhhhhh... They brought Lois Lane, a person who Supes barely knew, aboard their ship for more information. So clearly they had an interest in his personal life and the people close to him. And you said they're after his space ship, right? Well, where was the spaceship? In good ol' Kent farm. And Clark KNEW it was there because Pa Kent showed him. So, yeah he should have figured out that they were going to come for his mother. Just more lazy writing.
4): I agree, but it looked like he clearly thought it thru before doing it, since he really didn't want to kill Zod. So it seems like he knew the right way to go thru with it, especially with all the time he had while he was trying his best to prevent Zod from harming those people while he had him in a headlock.
The beam was so close to those people that turning Zod's head sharply to the right like he did would have killed them before it killed Zod. He didn't know the right way to go through with it, because the way he did it SHOULD have killed everyone there. Bad writing is bad, don't try to defend it.
5) & 6): they didn't care about advance strength & speed, they where only taking advantage of the lower gravity to help them while the humans where still around, since they where planning to terraform the planet, which earthlings can't survive on Krypton's planet. They wanted their home planet back and this was the best they could do' and it would have been the same except for a younger sun, which would only give them bonus abilities that non of them was even aware of. And the strength & speed they automatically got what sun exposure thanks to the suits blocking the rays of then sun, anyways they didn't care for extraodinary strength & speed, they are an advance race that just sees it as a toy that will no longer work as they would have gotten use to the gravity and become weaker in the universe for exploring other planets. Zod first time exposure was an accindent and hurt like hell, he never wanted to go back to that agianst. But he remember what superman said about honing senses and he now had a new helmet, so he could always put it back on by thinking it, if he couldn't have adopted...it was curiousity with no real risk. Plus Zod explained that he was rised since a child to honed all his senses to be the most elite warrior of Krypton (because their people are pre-determined to what they will grow up to be before they are even born, as already explained in the movie too), Superman unfortunately learned how to hone his senses on a farm by people who knew nothing on how to do so, as Zod made fun of Superman when he insulted about where did he learned how to hone his senses, on a farm (semi-accurate quote: "I was raised my whole life since I was a child to hone in all of my senses to be a warrior, where did you learned to hone your senses, on a farm")
So... you have a choice of living on a planet that gives you super strength and speed, or one that doesn't. You're going to choose no super strength? Yeah right.
When talking to Jorrel, he specifically said that terraforming the planet because it would take too long to adapt to Earth and would be too painful. Yet, he adapted pretty damn quick. He didn't have the helmet on during his final fight at all, and he was able to perform just fine. So, it didn't seem Earth's atmosphere was all that debilitating.Point is, it didn't seem too hard. And, since Kryptonians seem to like things like food and running water and electricity, destroying all of the planets seems pretty silly.
Now if you want to say "Zod just wanted to kill all the humans because he's a freaking dick". You can say that, and that would make sense, but that's not how the movie explained it.
7): they didn't terraform the planet to be normal, they did it to bring krypton back since the original home world was destroy, they where home sick since they awiken from the destruction of their planet, as you saw the female Villian cry during the flashback. Plus they didn't know that the sun would do anything to them, and after Zod, it could have been assumed that the nourishing atmosphere was to blame for Zod going thru all that pain.
Uhhhh... they did know the sun would strengthen them. They didn't have that kind of strength or speed from Krypton and low gravity alone isn't going to make them that much stronger and faster. And the Kryptonians had done a lot of space exploration and clearly knew the effects of different sons. The leader of their army should definitely know about things like this.
9): they didn't die, they ended up back in the phantom zone, which is where all life forms & things go to when they get sucked in by a black hole in this movie.
I'm not talking about the Kryptonians in the battle, I'm talking about the ones that traveled through space in the past to other planets like Earth. Jorrel (or maybe Zod, I forget) says that all of the Kryptonians died sometime after Krypton cut off their space program and left them on whatever planet they were. Why is this? How didn't more Kryptonians survive on those world, particularly when any world with a yellow son made them ridiculously strong?
10): it's not a satalite, but a drone, like the ones in the middle east in real life. He only mention he was from Kansas to 2 people, and the woman is not going to tell, and the guy will obviously be trustworthy too, since he is left in this movie to try to get people to believe that Superman is not a threat to America's interest. Superman even says that he will just have to trust him then. Lois never revealed the phony names he used, and she only knew of one of them by being with him which is the only thing that made it possible for her to back-track the other phony names he had lived under...plus her sources where willing to talk when superman was a nobody, but now they won't let anyone know of what name nor if he ever was there under each phony name and just deny it now, because Clark is now the great hero Superman who is always going to save earthlings every chance he can.
Eh... that's just reaching. Why is the random woman who just met him not go to tell her supervisors, hey he's from Kansas? And the point is that Lois had such little difficulty finding him that it can't be very hard for the US military to do the same.
