By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - PC Discussion - SimCity 67 metacritic so far

joesampson said:
Polygon dropped their review to a 4/10.

http://www.polygon.com/game/simcity-2013/2630


I feel sorry for Maxxis because they're the ones EA is going to blame for this. That said-- good. 

 

Thid has been beyond ridiculous and the fact that its likely to continue through the weekend is even worse. 



Around the Network

I wonder if some of the SimCity devs will quit.



http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/profile/92109/nintendopie/ Nintendopie  Was obviously right and I was obviously wrong. I will forever be a lesser being than them. (6/16/13)

Hopefully they just do a patch to make it not online only, and I'll want it even if it is a dumb downed version of the old ones.

It still looks like a ton of fun when it works.



Metacritic is down to 79 after Gamespot's score of 5/10



pezus said:
joesampson said:
Metacritic is down to 83 while the user score is 2.3. EA really killed the franchise. Small cities, no highways, subways, limited transportation options, no terraforming, no density zoning, and top top it off online drm that makes the game unplayable, what a disaster of a game. I wouldn't play this crap of a game if it was free.

82 now. Still only 12 reviews. I'm assuming more than 1 reviewer changed their score?

well once it's fixed won't they probably change their score back?



Around the Network
pezus said:
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/simcity/critic-reviews

Down to 76 and the Polygon score is still at 9.5 lol (History: 9.5 ->8->4 now)


Sadly Meta will only take the first score and won't change it.



Former something....

SIMCITY 2013: 76 with userscore 1.5 (!)
SIMCITY 4: 84 with userscore 8.6

Thank you EA.
Should've just let Maxis do their thing.

I still can't believe the stupidity. It was sooo easy. All SimCity fans were waiting for, including myself, was a SimCity 4-clone with more options for building, modern graphics with realistic effects and more in-depth simulation and statistics.

The sad thing is, metascore will only go down significantly, maybe even ending in the 60's! On one hand I hope this game flops hard, but on the other I know EA will just blame Maxis for this.



S.Peelman said:
SIMCITY 2013: 76 with userscore 1.5 (!)
SIMCITY 4: 84 with userscore 8.6

Thank you EA.
Should've just let Maxis do their thing.

I still can't believe the stupidity. It was sooo easy. All SimCity fans were waiting for, including myself, was a SimCity 4-clone with more options for building, modern graphics with realistic effects and more in-depth simulation and statistics.

The sad thing is, metascore will only go down significantly, maybe even ending in the 60's! On one hand I hope this game flops hard, but on the other I know EA will just blame Maxis for this.

itll get better over time (not score) with updates.  Just bad at launch but itll improve over time.




       

JayWood2010 said:
TruckOSaurus said:
Looks interesting but I don't feel like start an Origin account.


Origin isn't bad.  I don't understand peoples hate for it.  Steam wasnt that great when it started either.  Although the spyware was annoying with Origin


1. It's *another* DL service to keep track of....(convenience is nice).
2. It's EA.
3. Sim City.



Blacksaber said:
pezus said:
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/simcity/critic-reviews

Down to 76 and the Polygon score is still at 9.5 lol (History: 9.5 ->8->4 now)


Sadly Meta will only take the first score and won't change it.


This upset me a little at first, but then I realized that when places like Polygon put their back at 9.5, Metacritic won't change those either.  The low reviews all cite server problems so it looks like the game will settle in the 75 range.