38) Dragon Age: Origins (PC / 2009 / RPG)

One of the best RPGs of the generation. A huge overarching story, excellent characters and relationships, combat which is engaging if a little bit repetitive, and plenty of playtime. I don't much like the whole silent protagonist thing, but I can see why they went for it. My big problem with this is the linearity. You do have some sort of choice as to the order in which you explore different areas, but the areas themselves follow narrow corridor-like paths. Hopefully Dragon Age 3 can add some more exploration.

Clue for Game 37: Incredible single player experience, highly lackluster and peculiarly designed online. Derided by many for reasons that have nothing to do with the gameplay.

Mass Effect 3?

38th - Final Fantasy XII (PS2, 2007)
The first of two final fantasy games on my list, FFXII is also my second favourite Final Fantasy of all time. While shunned and disliked by a lot of fans, this iteration of the series stands on a lot of amazing accomplishments, like it's great battle system, character development (in terms of controlling how your character develops, the License Board is the best system on any FF), a pretty broad and well thought story (sadly tarnished by the departure of Matsuno. It had the potential to be so much more) and so much content to put most other RPGs to shame.
While a pretty great game, it does have it's share of flaws, with a big glaring one: It's completely weak main character, Vaan. Everything about the game screams "Basch is the main character!" or "Vaan is just a late-patched sucker!" because the entire game was indeed planned around Basch (one of the reasons I said that the game could have been so much more). 
It also features one of the best sidequest in any RPG I've ever played: The Hunt quests. While some are pretty meek fights, the later hunts are some pretty hard fights if you play the game entirely without the Gambit system (and yes, this system is OPTIONAL).

      

Number 37 will shout the hell out of you.

Skyrim?

Yeah, this one's pretty easy no matter what hint you use .

Yeah I meant bad girl...but you're right.

Nope; I love ME3's online.

You are close in that people deride this game because of something to do with storytelling, but in this case it is nothing to do with the ending.

Haha, right you are! That hint might've been a bit too easy.

Anyway, my number 38 is --> Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess!

I'd be lying if I said it was my favorite Zelda game, but that didn't make it any less fun once I really got going in the game. It looked great, and Midna was an awesome partner through and through. The ending to this one genuinely made me sad, too, which isn't something I often expect out of Zelda. Just a fun game overall.

Hint for 37: Mario's a popular guy.