Gamerace said:
HappySqurriel said:
If third party games were "bombing" like some people claim there should be games which fit the 3 of the following 4 conditions and sold poorly; If third party games were underperforming there should be a long list of games that fit 2 of the following 4 conditions and sold poorly. - Popular IP
- Popular Genre
- Heavily Marketed
- High Quality
The reality is that few third party games that have been released for the Wii satisfy any of those conditions, and those that statisfy one or more of these conditions tend to sell at an appropriate level. |
Madden and MoH:H2 come to mind. Madden is profittable but definately below-par for sales vs other systems. Not the greatest Madden ever, but well reviewed and fun. MoH:H2 big franchise (MoH), great reviews, popular genre - poor sales. I also disagree popular IP will have much effect. I think a lot of Wii owners either A) Never cared about most of the 'popular' franchises in the first place (I myself fall in this group) or B) Are new to gaming and only know the Mario, Sonics and Master Chiefs of the world. And MC is debatable for the average Joe. Instead I'd suggest a highly known franchise like Star Wars, D&D or James Bond might get more sales than Call of Duty or DMC or Ninja Gaiden (sp?) on Wii. Come to think of it, I wonder if the movies have helped RE4 / RE:UC sales on Wii.... |
In my opinion, Madden sold at an adequate level being that it was considered much lower quality than the XBox 360 or PS3 version, and the marketing campaign was focused entirely on the XBox 360; if I remember correctly, the advertizements that played on TV didn't even have a PS3 or Wii symbol. Overall, it will break 500,000 units before Madden 09 is released ...
Medal of Honor: Heroes 2 has underperformed in North America, and will probably only sell 200,000 units here; it may see similar sales in "the Other" regions and end up with total sales around 500,000 units. The game was not really marketed (that I saw), it was a good game but not a great game, the IP has steadily been damaged by over-use and lower quality games (Medal of Honor: Vanguard), and the content material of the game (WWII shooter) is getting tired.
I'm not saying I fully disagree with you (these games could have sold better) but neither game is really a poster child for under apprieciated games that bombed. In general, these games would have sold better if they were higher quality and marketed more heavily; and their (worldwide) sales are not that bad for what the games are.