It looks like I have to be fast next week.

It was definetly a flop userbase wise, going from a big userbase of FFX to such a small userbase. But business wise it wasn't since its still making them money.

If it didn't pass 5 Million retail that would be bad.

None.

But one thing that can be compared with other MMOs are long-term revenues.

You need to start distinguishing between non-MMO and MMO RPG installments.  They require a different metric of success and you seem to agree based on what you said.  "Business wise" is what matters for an MMO.  FFXI was not a flop by any means if it made Square tons of money vis-a-vis subscriptions. 

Therefore, saying DQX did horrible for a DQ game (not an MMO game) is a little silly given that we won't know how well it's done until a long time from now.  But I understand why you would choose to look at DQX's first week as an ordinary DQ entry rather than an MMO entry... ;)

Wow! DQX really boosted the Wii hardware sales! And it's software sales surpassed my expectations! (Expected 250K-350K first week)

For Onitore, if we take digital sales into account, then its 2nd week should be on par with Brain Age 1's 2nd week (like the first week). Still need more time to see if Onitore will have massive legs or not.

NSMB2's sales......... could Malstrom actually be correct in saying that NSMB2 will fail? I hope not. :(

Well, remember... Monster Hunter 3 tri was a flop even when Capcom announced that they were very pleased with it's LTD.  Some games are just a flop because they're on a Nintendo system and not a Sony system to be quite honest.

3DSLL – 82,251

3DS – 42,164

Vita – 9,038

Nintendo 3DS is a freaking beast, Poor vita back below 10k on both trackers.

That's quite a bump for Wii.

I called 400k. Im pretty happy with that prediction. Nice boost for Wii too.