You may disagree, as long as you understand that:
1) FPSs are always better on the PC (in almost every aspect, looks, controls, gameplay)
2) It is not the amount of keys in the keyboard that make it great, if that was true, cell phone games would be better than any portable game.

If this is about making assumptions, I`d say this is coming from someone that does not play a lot of games. Half Life 2 may be easier than a lot of games to customize, but it is not a breeze. There are commands for jump, duck, run, walk, crawl, reload, use, flashlight, secondary fire, switch weapon and a button for each weapon. Jump, run and reload are in a comforable position (my settings) - shift, control, space. The others need my pointer or middle finger. And let`s not even talk about games like Farcry. In addition to HL commands, you have binoculars, cry vision, hold breath, grenade, cycle grenades, drop weapon, zoom and some that I forgot. That is without taking into consideration multiplayer only features. If you know a setting that could make pressing all these buttons fast and intuitive, please tell me. My point is that I think that most of these commands are not used enough to demand individual buttons.

Customizing on controllers are very different from keyboards and that is not a matter of which one is better. Keyboard is almost 100% customizable, controllers config, in most cases, make you chose between predetermined settings (like type A, B, C). Even in games that allow customization, you can not set the fire or jump command to buttons like select or start (not that anyone sane would do it). Keyboards on the other hand allow for some bizarre combos (that does not mean it is bad). For example, I use the right mouse button to walk forward, ASD for strafing, QE to lean, click wheel for zoom and W for secondary fire.

How can you walk in a FPS without your fingers on the WASD keys? Psychic powers? 100% of the time is impossible (that is a semantic trick), but I keep them on these keys 90% of the time. Unless you play strategy based FPS, which keep you behind walls and crates all the time, you must use the said keys.

As for the jab on the last paragraph ... Maybe you should play more than 3 genres of games, that way you`d think of ways to improve controls other than more buttons.

I have it but haven't gotten around to playing it just yet.

Having played MP3 for an extended period of time, I have to say I wasnt blown away by the controls. Ill stick with a keyboard and mouse.

I will have to disagree, i think alot of things can distract your shooting whilst playing the wii, perhaps you feel tired and still want to keep playing?

Or you are shaking or something - i dunno you get my point, i think it K+M will always be more precise and you can customise it so much better + i think it would be a tad hard trying to snipe some dudes head off when you cant keep still or something, you dont really have to worry about that with a keyboard and mouse.

Confused about your point Jessman, if you can't keep still you would shake the mouse as much as a wii mote.

Not entirely, if you have a precision gaming surface and a nice heavy comfy mouse you its excellent, but when your playing the wii your arm is extended so its kinda awkward in some area's

I play FPS's on the Wii with the wiimote on my lap, not extended :P But I can see where you are coming from, I just never found a point in extending my arm.

I can't seem to remember an FPS on a console that utilized the left analog stick to a degree that a PC user could not do. Most FPSs simply have you walk forward, backward, strafe left or right, or a combination of those when pushing the stick diagonally. There's really no point to tip-toeing or walking slowly in most FPSs.

How do many of these commands differ from console games? I usually customize my controls if the game allows me to. In fact, I changed up most of the commands on The Orange Box on the PS3.

Why does it matter if the keyboard can be customized? Do it to your liking rather than complain about the weird como's you can make out of it. Hell, multi-player commands don't really add a whole lot other than a chat, team chat, and scoreboard (unless it's main feature is online like BF2, CS, or TF2).

Walking depends on the game. You almost don't need it in Half-Life 2 except to be careful from falling. Usually walk can be shift which means the pinky can have you walk while you can still jump, duck, move around, and use other keys. Again, customize it to your liking and it's not like you have to have three fingers glued to w, s, a, and d. 

Whats funny then is how you made this thread NOW instead of waiting till LATER when more games would support your thoughts. I don't know about others, but I've also been playing on controllers for years as well and I still feel the way I do.