By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Inafune (Mega Man creator) praises Fish's for saying Japanese games suck

Nem said:
stealth20k said:
 

Was I suppose to know you were generalizing to make a point?

Japanese dev on consoles has been less prominent simply due to popularity.......thats realy all it came down too...........With valkjyria, star ocean 4, and more on consoles I would never say it were bad............

 

Monster hunter is better than 99 percent of the generic western mmo garbage...............I would take phantasy star over wow any day of the week.

"japan development hid in the PSP cause it had no other choice. It was the same as admiting they couldnt take on home consoles, wich was the case."

Funny false generalization............Your right, japan had no choice with the ps3 not popular at all, and the psp mega popular, it was an easy choice to make. You saying they couldnt make it on consoles is just a fanboyish thing to say

First point i'll make is: the japanese refused to move over to the next-gen at the time it come out due to pure nationalism (refused to buy the 360 for the whole year it was out ahead of the PS3). It was a shot in the foot. Sorry if not everyone is that irrational about their purchases.

Without a home market, of course the portable market becomes popular, theres no other choice! With the delay, japan was just too late and couldnt adapt to the new consoles. This is what happened. The atempts at calling me fanboy of something im not sure of, i really cant make sense of.


But i have to bite "generic western MMO garbage"? I have no idea what you're talking about.

The  grindfest garbage comes from Korea and Japan.

I dont think theres are even so many western MMO's to make an average out of. Lets see... D&DOnline, Age of conan, WoW, SWTOR, Guild Wars, RIFT and EVE? Mind you these are games with incredible content support, it certainly isnt PSO v2.0. I would like to know what is "generic" about it, assuming you meant generic as a bad thing.

1) Your first point is pure foolish fanboyness

2) Your generalizing, sensationazing, and not looking at the whole picture

3) Way to go dragging korea into your hate

 



Around the Network
bonkers555 said:

After finishing the 1st chapter of Tales of Grace F I now realize that I'm completely done with the Jrpgs genre. At least Nintendo will never let me down with their Japanese games.


Yeah because a 60-80 hour game you can get the vibe for in 1 hour...................please, I doubt you even own it

 

And there is no "jrpgs genre" that doesnt make any sense



stealth20k said:
DRAGON QUEST WAS NOT THE FIRST RPG ANYTHING. Lets get that straight

Ultima, dunjonquest, and others came long long before...........

Dragon Quest may not have been the first game to use experience points; but it was the first game to use experience points, while having a true RPG battle system (as opposed to a typed command based one, which is more typical of a text adventure), as well as in game character dialogue and a storyline - which are he four essential elements for the RPG genre. I don't see how the first three Ultima games could be considered to be RPGs; at best they are proto-RPGs, but are best defined merely as dungeon crawlers with some RPG elements lifted off of Pen and paper RPGs like Dungeons of Dragons.  

The first Ultima game that can be considered to be a real RPG would be the NES remake of Ultima 3, but that came out just a short time before Dragon Quest 3 was released. The NES version of Ultima 3 (which had story, in game dialogue not available in the original version) was the first non-Japanese videogame which had the basic core components that the RPG genre requires.

Also, RPGs developed in the west followed the trends which started with Dragon Quest; such as integrating character dialogue, having storylines, and using a more simplistic menu based battle system (rather than typing a bunch of crap to do stuff). Many games not considered RPGs today have more RPG elements than those pre-Dragon Quest Ultima and Wizardry games had.



I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.

pezus said:
bonkers555 said:

After finishing the 1st chapter of Tales of Grace F I now realize that I'm completely done with the Jrpgs genre. At least Nintendo will never let me down with their Japanese games.

After finishing Mass Effect 3 I now realize I'm completely done with the WRPG genre. Do you realize how silly it sounds say something like this? What, you didn't like this game and therefore the whole genre sucks?

I don't think the whole genre sucks, I just think the genre sucks this gen on home consoles. Most of the good JRPG we are getting are only availability on the PSP and DS. Regarding WRPG, I never finish a game from that genre so I can't give you a opinion. Witcher 2 is the first WRPG game that I enjoying and might finish, a first for me for these type of game.



stealth20k said:
Nem said:
stealth20k said:
 

Was I suppose to know you were generalizing to make a point?

Japanese dev on consoles has been less prominent simply due to popularity.......thats realy all it came down too...........With valkjyria, star ocean 4, and more on consoles I would never say it were bad............

 

Monster hunter is better than 99 percent of the generic western mmo garbage...............I would take phantasy star over wow any day of the week.

"japan development hid in the PSP cause it had no other choice. It was the same as admiting they couldnt take on home consoles, wich was the case."

Funny false generalization............Your right, japan had no choice with the ps3 not popular at all, and the psp mega popular, it was an easy choice to make. You saying they couldnt make it on consoles is just a fanboyish thing to say

First point i'll make is: the japanese refused to move over to the next-gen at the time it come out due to pure nationalism (refused to buy the 360 for the whole year it was out ahead of the PS3). It was a shot in the foot. Sorry if not everyone is that irrational about their purchases.

Without a home market, of course the portable market becomes popular, theres no other choice! With the delay, japan was just too late and couldnt adapt to the new consoles. This is what happened. The atempts at calling me fanboy of something im not sure of, i really cant make sense of.


But i have to bite "generic western MMO garbage"? I have no idea what you're talking about.

The  grindfest garbage comes from Korea and Japan.

I dont think theres are even so many western MMO's to make an average out of. Lets see... D&DOnline, Age of conan, WoW, SWTOR, Guild Wars, RIFT and EVE? Mind you these are games with incredible content support, it certainly isnt PSO v2.0. I would like to know what is "generic" about it, assuming you meant generic as a bad thing.

1) Your first point is pure foolish fanboyness

2) Your generalizing, sensationazing, and not looking at the whole picture

3) Way to go dragging korea into your hate

 

I think its funny how you keep trying to label me fanboy or spreading hate over something else, even though you dont really know what exactly. I'm analysing facts.

I was actually looking forward to some rationale, but i guess there is none behind your arguments.



Around the Network

I havent seen 1 fact yet from anything youve uttered.

Me too, you arent providing the rationale others have

=



bonkers555 said:
pezus said:
bonkers555 said:

After finishing the 1st chapter of Tales of Grace F I now realize that I'm completely done with the Jrpgs genre. At least Nintendo will never let me down with their Japanese games.

After finishing Mass Effect 3 I now realize I'm completely done with the WRPG genre. Do you realize how silly it sounds say something like this? What, you didn't like this game and therefore the whole genre sucks?

I don't think the whole genre sucks, I just think the genre sucks this gen on home consoles. Most of the good JRPG we are getting are only availability on the PSP and DS. Regarding WRPG, I never finish a game from that genre so I can't give you a opinion. Witcher 2 is the first WRPG game that I enjoying and might finish, a first for me for these type of game.


Even thats a generalizaton.......disgaea 4, star ocean 4, valkyria, and tales are all awesome console rpgs.........and yes whatever systems are most popular get the bulk. Just because some systems get the bulk doesnt mean there isnt quality elsewhere.........



Jumpin said:
stealth20k said:
DRAGON QUEST WAS NOT THE FIRST RPG ANYTHING. Lets get that straight

Ultima, dunjonquest, and others came long long before...........

Dragon Quest may not have been the first game to use experience points; but it was the first game to use experience points, while having a true RPG battle system (as opposed to a typed command based one, which is more typical of a text adventure), as well as in game character dialogue and a storyline - which are he four essential elements for the RPG genre. I don't see how the first three Ultima games could be considered to be RPGs; at best they are proto-RPGs, but are best defined merely as dungeon crawlers with some RPG elements lifted off of Pen and paper RPGs like Dungeons of Dragons.  

The first Ultima game that can be considered to be a real RPG would be the NES remake of Ultima 3, but that came out just a short time before Dragon Quest 3 was released. The NES version of Ultima 3 (which had story, in game dialogue not available in the original version) was the first non-Japanese videogame which had the basic core components that the RPG genre requires.

Also, RPGs developed in the west followed the trends which started with Dragon Quest; such as integrating character dialogue, having storylines, and using a more simplistic menu based battle system (rather than typing a bunch of crap to do stuff). Many games not considered RPGs today have more RPG elements than those pre-Dragon Quest Ultima and Wizardry games had.


How can I ague with someone who is too young to know what hes talking about............true RPG battle system's where around since the early 80's........dragon quest just added to the formula, it didnt invent it

Ultima wasnt even the first



I like japanese games more than western ones
just my opinion
i dont give a fawk about what they say



stealth20k said:
bonkers555 said:
pezus said:
bonkers555 said:

After finishing the 1st chapter of Tales of Grace F I now realize that I'm completely done with the Jrpgs genre. At least Nintendo will never let me down with their Japanese games.

After finishing Mass Effect 3 I now realize I'm completely done with the WRPG genre. Do you realize how silly it sounds say something like this? What, you didn't like this game and therefore the whole genre sucks?

I don't think the whole genre sucks, I just think the genre sucks this gen on home consoles. Most of the good JRPG we are getting are only availability on the PSP and DS. Regarding WRPG, I never finish a game from that genre so I can't give you a opinion. Witcher 2 is the first WRPG game that I enjoying and might finish, a first for me for these type of game.


Even thats a generalizaton.......disgaea 4, star ocean 4, valkyria, and tales are all awesome console rpgs.........and yes whatever systems are most popular get the bulk. Just because some systems get the bulk doesnt mean there isnt quality elsewhere.........

Metacritic:

Disagaea 4: 82.54%

Star Ocean 4 International: 76.62%

Vakyria chronicles: 87.3%

 

Just from this and last year:

Skyrim: 95.22%

Mass effect 3: 92.19%

The witcher 2 enhanced edition: 90.29%

Source: www.gamerankings.com

 

You're in denial. You are purposely putting your personal feelings where your head is and its why you cant objectively analyse.

There is a problem, and like i said in my first post, there are exceptions, but there is no denying the trend, wether you like it or not.