+ Mario Kart
- Heart Gold / Soul Silver

Michael-5 said: morenoingrato said: Note to editor ( ): It is the fourth time Atma has voted Chrono down. Actually it's his third. The 4th last vote wasn't counted because that was his 4th time counting DXIX/Chrono. I made him double vote on his last vote to replace the invalid one from before. If he +DQIX/-CT votes next time, then that will be invalid. Thanks for watching out though. + Dragon Quest IX -TWEWY BTW atma and you. Why don't you guys call a truce? Both DXIX and Chrono Trigger are similar types of JRPG's, and I wouldn't mind seeing them both do well in this thread. Your attacking each other and if you keep it up these games will end up 5th/6th. atma I know you might legitimatly want to see CT finally off the chart, but is it worth killing DQIX for?  Mario Kart DS -66HP  Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver -61HP The World Ends With You -38HP Pokemon Black/White -34HP  Dragon Quest IX: Sentinals of the Starry Sky -32HP  Chrono Trigger -28HP

Ok I can put aside Chrono Trigger for now but I don't think a port game deserves its place among the top 5 best DS game at all. The DS library is one of the greatest I have seen since a long time and deserves more. Chrono Trigger's place is among top 5 SNES game not DS.

Anyway here is my vote:

+Pokemon Black/White

-Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver

+ Dragon Quest IX
- The World Ends With You

+ Pokemon Black/White
- The World ends with you(Only one I havent played)

+Dragon Quest IX
-Mario Kart DS

atma998 said: Michael-5 said: morenoingrato said: Note to editor ( ): It is the fourth time Atma has voted Chrono down. Actually it's his third. The 4th last vote wasn't counted because that was his 4th time counting DXIX/Chrono. I made him double vote on his last vote to replace the invalid one from before. If he +DQIX/-CT votes next time, then that will be invalid. Thanks for watching out though. BTW atma and you. Why don't you guys call a truce? Both DXIX and Chrono Trigger are similar types of JRPG's, and I wouldn't mind seeing them both do well in this thread. Your attacking each other and if you keep it up these games will end up 5th/6th. atma I know you might legitimatly want to see CT finally off the chart, but is it worth killing DQIX for? Ok I can put aside Chrono Trigger for now but I don't think a port game deserves its place among the top 5 best DS game at all. The DS library is one of the greatest I have seen since a long time and deserves more. Chrono Trigger's place is among top 5 SNES game not DS.

Well lets see if nomoreingrato follows suit. The way I look at Chrono Trigger is as a testiment to old JRPG fans. Chrono Trigger is arguably the best JRPG ever made, and games of this calibur, but low sales, almost never get remade or ported. Other examples are FFVII and Super Mario RPG.

Also ontop of that, Chrono Trigger was soo good at the time, new gamers will still love this game despite it's dated gameplay/graphics. I first played it last gen, and it's now my favorite game of all time.

Anyway, it would suck to see DQIX not get the top spot, so I hope you two can be peaceful about it. I think you both want to see HeartGold/SoulSilver fall.

+DQIX

-Mario Kart DS

 Mario Kart DS -54HP

 Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver -54HP

 Dragon Quest IX: Sentinals of the Starry Sky -41HP

Pokemon Black/White -40HP

 Chrono Trigger -28HP

The World Ends With You -28HP

+ TWEWY

- DQIX

+ Dragon Quest IX
- Pokemon Black/White

I hate voting down a game I love so much... :(, but in some ways it feels wrong for there to be two Pokemon games in the top 5. I wonder how this will all turn out. Nothing is safe from "-" points at this point.

+ The World Ends with You

- Pokemon B&W

+ Chrono Trigger
- Heart Gold