By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - The Uncharted 3 OVER Battlefield 3(X360) CLUB!!! Update 12 sept.

Wagram on 10 August 2011

I'll be purchasing U3 but not battlefield. Too lazy to put my Pre-Order in though.



Around the Network
Mordred11 on 10 August 2011
Wagram said:
I'll be purchasing U3 but not battlefield. Too lazy to put my Pre-Order in though.

So who do you think will win?



non-gravity on 10 August 2011

This club is bound to burn. Battlefield will win.



blkfish92 on 10 August 2011

I still think U3 will get goty by some company, it's going to happen.



           

Wagram on 10 August 2011
Mordred11 said:
Wagram said:
I'll be purchasing U3 but not battlefield. Too lazy to put my Pre-Order in though.

So who do you think will win?

Not sure really. Uncharted has MASSIVE legs. I don't believe the Pre-Orders will make a difference in its lifetime sales.

Battlefield could royally stomp Uncharted or it may not. I honestly have no idea who will win this.



Around the Network
yo_john117 on 10 August 2011

I think I will have to be out (but just barely!)

Either way it will be really close!



Mordred11 on 10 August 2011

So far,we have :

IN :  1.Mordred11

2.SqueakySamurai

3.nightsurge

4.Boutros

5.spurgeonryan

OUT:   1.Munkeh111
2.Seece
3.pezus
4.snakenobi
5.enrageorange
6.Millenium
7.JayWood2010
8.BenVTrigger
9.Jay520
10.sales2099
11.CGI-Quality
12.non-gravity
13.yo_john117

Oh boy...this is getting exciting haha.



Boutros on 10 August 2011

I like where I stand in this thread because in either cases I can turn things to my advantage



Jaywood2010 on 10 August 2011
Mordred11 said:
JayWood2010 said:
This is just dumb. First off Uncharted 1 and 2 both sold very well, yes. Bad Company 1 and 2 also sold well on 360. However this is Battlefield 3, not Bad Company. Much bigger name, and with the advertising they will be doing, it has a chance to break 5 mil on 360, maybe even 6. Uncharted 1 and 2 are amazing game which can also sale 5 mil. Instead of making 2 games that are completely different genres a comparison, how about doing a 3rd person shooter (Uncharted) vs a another 3rd person shooter (Gears of War). That is a better comparison. It's why you see Battlerfield 3 vs ModernWarfare 3. Because they are under the same genre. Regardless, Battlefield 3 will be the 3rd most sold game of the year on 360, and the 2nd most sold multiplatform game.

Why would I make a U3 vs GoW3 thread,when that has been made over and over again on all gaming forums?And it's pretty obvious that GoW3 will outsell U3,it's pointless to make a thread about it.

I made this thread because these 2 games are releasing close to eachother,and both have chances to outsell the counterpart.

And besides GoW3,there is no other 3rd person shooter that can beat/come close to U3 that's being released anytime soon.I don't see a problem in the difference of genres,since Uncharted has proven that it can outsell the majority of FPS's.

Battlefield 3 will outsell uncharted 3 simple as that.  No matter which way you look at it.  Your comparison is just awful.  You chose two different consoles, two different genres, and you chose a multiplatform game vs an exclusive. Lets put it this way,  a lot of ppl including myself has multiple consoles and will have to make the choice on which system to buy BF3 on.  I believe the numbers will look something like this, 6 mil on 360, and 3.5 mil on PS3.  But lets say Uncharted 3 was muiltiplatform,  The numbers would then be split.  And in that case it would look like this prob, 4 mil on PS3, and 2 mil on 360.  If you are going to make comparisons, do it in a fair way. And the "Club" thing makes it sound even more dumb btw




       

dsage01 on 10 August 2011
Mordred11 said:

So far,we have :

IN :  1.Mordred11

2.SqueakySamurai

3.nightsurge

4.dsage01

5.Boutros

6.spurgeonryan

OUT:   1.Munkeh111
2.Seece
3.pezus
4.snakenobi
5.enrageorange
6.Millenium
7.JayWood2010
8.BenVTrigger
9.Jay520
10.sales2099
11.CGI-Quality
12.non-gravity
13.yo_john117

Oh boy...this is getting exciting haha.


I think you might want to remove me from the in list. Unless Battlefield 3 gets a really bad meta it's not gonna happen. But if Battlefield 3 matches or gets around BF2 ratings I think it should be more like this.

Battlefield 3 (360) 7 million

Uncharted 3: 6 million

Battlefield 3: (PS3) 5.4 million