By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - *Best Wii Third Party Elimination Game*

flagstaad said:
gumby_trucker said:

for the record, I think killing off MH when there are objectively far worse games on the list is a bit hateful. Even if the game isn't for you, you can't deny that far more effort was put into it than most 3rd party Wii games. Incidentally, I am only voting the way I am to counter what I view as unfair.

Frankly, if MH dies so early, this thread loses all objectivity IMO.

That can be said for many games in the list, besides If this keeps you and MrT-Tar busy trying to save the game all the other more random players can vote without worry that you are going to sunk their games. It is a win-win situation.

+ Trauma Center

- Monster Hunter

Really?

Do you honestly expect me to believe you think Muramsa had more effort put into it than MHTri? A 20 hour single player 2-D game vs. a 200 hour 3-D multiplayer (local and online) open world game with an additional story mode and actual customization that goes beyond changing the stats and reusing the same sprites?? Or Trauma Center, which has less content than a decent sized point and click adventure?? Or a god-damned Rail Shooter running on the RE4 engine and using old assets from previous games??

I'm not saying these games don't deserve a place on the list of quality 3rd party games, but the inflation caused by your point-spamming is quickly making this thread lose all touch with reality. If I tally up your recent posts it comes out that MHtri is a worse game than Sonic, for christ's sake!

You're just trolling in order to attract attention, and trying to derail this thread.



Until you've played it, every game is a system seller!

the original trolls

Wii FC: 4810 9420 3131 7558
MHTri: name=BOo BoO/ID=BZBLEX/region=US

mini-games on consoles, cinematic games on handhelds, what's next? GameBoy IMAX?

Official Member of the Pikmin Fan Club

Around the Network

+Monster Hunter
-FIFA



Until you've played it, every game is a system seller!

the original trolls

Wii FC: 4810 9420 3131 7558
MHTri: name=BOo BoO/ID=BZBLEX/region=US

mini-games on consoles, cinematic games on handhelds, what's next? GameBoy IMAX?

Official Member of the Pikmin Fan Club

Michael-5 said:

Not Really. What game of yours did you like that deserved to die? Muramasa? I was the one who voted that down, but as soon as other people stopped voting for it, I let go. I do honestly want to see a fair thread.

Also I have yet to thumb up Monster Hunter, haven't you seen most of my votes are varied? I will only start to vote for Monster Hunter when I feel it is in danger, it doesn't deserve to die.

I am not saying anything about you, you vote balanced, and change both the plus and minus games, I did that for a while till noticed that not all players were like that. I am putting pressure on those players as they keep posting the same games over, and over again, now they have to do it to save the one game they want to win and can't focus on other games. If you see I am changing the plus game, from time to time I have most games of the list, and I like some more than others but this is a way to keep people worry about their games without eliminating them, other reason why I choose one that was on the top of the list.



flagstaad said:
Michael-5 said:

Not Really. What game of yours did you like that deserved to die? Muramasa? I was the one who voted that down, but as soon as other people stopped voting for it, I let go. I do honestly want to see a fair thread.

Also I have yet to thumb up Monster Hunter, haven't you seen most of my votes are varied? I will only start to vote for Monster Hunter when I feel it is in danger, it doesn't deserve to die.

I am not saying anything about you, you vote balanced, and change both the plus and minus games, I did that for a while till noticed that not all players were like that. I am putting pressure on those players as they keep posting the same games over, and over again, now they have to do it to save the one game they want to win and can't focus on other games. If you see I am changing the plus game, from time to time I have most games of the list, and I like some more than others but this is a way to keep people worry about their games without eliminating them, other reason why I choose one that was on the top of the list.

what games exactly were eliminated that you hold so dearly?

The Conduit? Dead Space Extraction?



Until you've played it, every game is a system seller!

the original trolls

Wii FC: 4810 9420 3131 7558
MHTri: name=BOo BoO/ID=BZBLEX/region=US

mini-games on consoles, cinematic games on handhelds, what's next? GameBoy IMAX?

Official Member of the Pikmin Fan Club

flagstaad said:
Michael-5 said:

Not Really. What game of yours did you like that deserved to die? Muramasa? I was the one who voted that down, but as soon as other people stopped voting for it, I let go. I do honestly want to see a fair thread.

Also I have yet to thumb up Monster Hunter, haven't you seen most of my votes are varied? I will only start to vote for Monster Hunter when I feel it is in danger, it doesn't deserve to die.

I am not saying anything about you, you vote balanced, and change both the plus and minus games, I did that for a while till noticed that not all players were like that. I am putting pressure on those players as they keep posting the same games over, and over again, now they have to do it to save the one game they want to win and can't focus on other games. If you see I am changing the plus game, from time to time I have most games of the list, and I like some more than others but this is a way to keep people worry about their games without eliminating them, other reason why I choose one that was on the top of the list.

Yea, but gumpy_trucker didn't always vote up Monster Hunter, and his thumb down usually varries. Just don't let the HP get too low okay? Putting pressure on the game is one thing, killing it is another. An eye for and eye makes the whole world blind, forcing people to vote 1 game because you put so much pressure on it doesn't allow other people to vote for other franchises they like, so the thread will be more about what you like. Just be fair.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

Around the Network
gumby_trucker said:

Really?

Do you honestly expect me to believe you think Muramsa had more effort put into it than MHTri? A 20 hour single player 2-D game vs. a 200 hour 3-D multiplayer (local and online) open world game with an additional story mode and actual customization that goes beyond changing the stats and reusing the same sprites?? Or Trauma Center, which has less content than a decent sized point and click adventure?? Or a god-damned Rail Shooter running on the RE4 engine and using old assets from previous games??

I do believe that a small company with a limited budget trying to release a different kind of game, of a new franchise in an unknow enviroment is as worthy of winning that a game of a know franchise that was sure to sell several millions, that had a big budget and was from a big company. I know I had more fun with those games than from Monster Hunter.

gumby_trucker said:

You're just trolling in order to attract attention, and trying to derail this thread.

I am not trolling, just voting according to the rules.



+ Monster Hunter
- Skate it



flagstaad said:
gumby_trucker said:

Really?

Do you honestly expect me to believe you think Muramsa had more effort put into it than MHTri? A 20 hour single player 2-D game vs. a 200 hour 3-D multiplayer (local and online) open world game with an additional story mode and actual customization that goes beyond changing the stats and reusing the same sprites?? Or Trauma Center, which has less content than a decent sized point and click adventure?? Or a god-damned Rail Shooter running on the RE4 engine and using old assets from previous games??

I do believe that a small company with a limited budget trying to release a different kind of game, of a new franchise in an unknow enviroment is as worthy of winning that a game of a know franchise that was sure to sell several millions, that had a big budget and was from a big company. I know I had more fun with those games than from Monster Hunter.

gumby_trucker said:

You're just trolling in order to attract attention, and trying to derail this thread.

I am not trolling, just voting according to the rules.

Your argument is valid and welcome, but the timing leaves a lot to be desired.... When there are ten games left on the list (which IMO should include games like the Trauma Series and No More Heroes at that point, just to be clear) then we can start debating the pros and cons of a big franchise game vs. a small budget original game. But as long as there are so many less worthy games still on the list there is no reason for you to go after Monster Hunter in particular. Furthermore, if that's your main agenda (going after big franchises), why target MH exclusively when the same could be said about Sonic or GoldenEye or the RE games?

I don't think you honestly believe MH is worse than Sonic or Just Dance or RE Chronicles... Not if you've played those games.
That's why I think you're trolling.



Until you've played it, every game is a system seller!

the original trolls

Wii FC: 4810 9420 3131 7558
MHTri: name=BOo BoO/ID=BZBLEX/region=US

mini-games on consoles, cinematic games on handhelds, what's next? GameBoy IMAX?

Official Member of the Pikmin Fan Club

+Monster Hunter
- No More Heroes



gumby_trucker said:

Your argument is valid and welcome, but the timing leaves a lot to be desired.... When there are ten games left on the list (which IMO should include games like the Trauma Series and No More Heroes at that point, just to be clear) then we can start debating the pros and cons of a big franchise game vs. a small budget original game. But as long as there are so many less worthy games still on the list there is no reason for you to go after Monster Hunter in particular. Furthermore, if that's your main agenda (going after big franchises), why target MH exclusively when the same could be said about Sonic or GoldenEye or the RE games?

I don't think you honestly believe MH is worse than Sonic or Just Dance or RE Chronicles... Not if you've played those games.
That's why I think you're trolling.

I didn't believe that games like Dead Space or The Conduit were worse than Carnival Games, Deca Sports, Game Party, Zumba Fitness, Skate It, Michael Jackson: The experience and many more, but I saw that MrT-Tar was playing with fixed options till it killed a game, and if it works for him why change the strategy?, besides I know a lot of people like that game and they will not let it die, that is why I choose the top one instead of a smaller one, otherwise it will be dead by this moment.

By the way, just 4 days ago, you even congratulate him for the strategy. And were using a similar one.

gumby_trucker said:

Indeed! Nice job on that one! Who's your next target?

Now that is being applied to one of your games is trolling, right?