Which one will sell better?

Halo:

Halo is one of the best selling FPS series and was a mega hit since the first one. High scores and hype drived this game foward along with it's amazing online multiplayer which is still at its finest and Halo is the Xbox's killer app. But can 343 industires do a good job of making the remake of the highest rated FPS in the world? The critics will be harsh but then again the name "Halo" makes everyone excited but with big guns like AC, Uncharted 3, Call of Duty and Battlefield will a Halo remake be able to survive?

Uncharted 3: 

This is one of the biggest surprises when Uncharted first launched it was a sales dissapointment But there was a good word of mouth for this game and it became a sales hit. But the story isn't over people couldn't have thought that Uncharted 2 would sell more. But a metascore of 96 changed everything. It is not exaclty the "Halo or Gran Turismo seller" but it is one of the best selling PS3 games despite being very new game series it is selling amazing. But the real question is can it outsell Halo CE? It's pretty obvious this remake won't sell as good as the the main Hala games and this will be the biggest Uncharted yet.

So will Uncharted 3 outsell Halo CE? Yes or no?

Lifetime, something like:

8 million Halo
6 million Uncharted

Halo CEA is a remake of a 10 year old game, but its also Halo...

I Think Halo CEA will sell 7 million LT
And Uncharted 3 will sell 6 million LT

Close...

Seeing as how Halo 3: ODST outsold Uncharted 2 by over a million units.... AND how Halo CE will likely be bigger than ODST by quite a bit...

Will UC3 outsell CE? I'll give you a firm NO. A better question would be can UC3 outsell ODST, which is nearing six million units. That would be a good match

Really!? come on everyone knows halo will

I think Halo CEA will sell similar to Halo 3: ODST

6 Million... Ish. 6.5 possibly.

Uncharted 3 will do anywhere between 4.5 to 5.5 Million units. 6 Million tops.

Halo CE for sure. I mean I cannot think of a situation where Uncharted 3 will blow past 6 Mil like Halo CE.

Halo Combat Evolved remake should easily outsell Uncharted 3. As others have said it will probably sell around ODST number maybe even a little better being the remake of many fans favorite Halo and being priced well at only $40.

Well for the time being

Anyway Halo CEA has this in the bag as far as i'm concerned....I mean anything is possible but it just doesn't seem probable.

Its confirmed 40 I have the statement from MS at work.