I agree WTH is just cause and the other unworth games doing in that list!

replace those with MGS4 or heavy rain or battlefield 2 or dead space 2!

No way MGS4 deserves to be on this list, or battlefield 2.  MGS4 was amazing at its time but has far been passed.  Same thing for the people claiming Uncharted 1.  It was the best when it was released but many games have now passed it.

The ones I think really strike me as missing are Heavy Rain, Alan Wake, and Mass Effect 2.  Those seem like for sure lock ins on a top ten list.

Its NOT lazy to use a single color palette.....when your on an alien planet.

Killzone's not happening on the Earth man, that is Uncharted and crysis. Killzone is happening on some alien planet that is not so good for human inhabitation and imo they have nailed the artistic graphics right on the head with killzone.

The scene and everything is captured perfectly in killzone and to this date it is astonishing to me how the hell did guerilla imagine such an amazing universe. Lightning through the skies, gaseous clouds in the sky, winds blowing throughout the region, sky colour, the water and reflections, the desert, with the quiet feeling that nobody is around you and the insects on top of that, no other game matches the artisitc imagination of Killzone in the top 5 graphical kings.

I prefer the way killzone is. I don't want it to be a rainbow Uncharted copycat, there are other games for that.

IMO MGS4 and BF bad company 2 still looks amazing and still looks better than a lot of games out there.

I don't like the list.

Alan Wake looks better than Gears of War 2.

God of War 3 looks better than Uncharted and Killzone.

It kind of isn't fair that Killzone was added twice, even though it may very well been deserving, they could have given a chance to a different IP.

Vanquish looks better than Gears of War 2.

Does Dirt 2 look better than Forza 3 and GT5? Don't really now, always thought the other two took that lead.

Just Cause 2 shouldn't be on the list, it's a gorgeous game, but it's gorgeous because it tricks you. From a distance, everything looks fantastic, but as soon as you get closer to the enemies, the buildings, the mountains and the trees, it starts to look rough.

Personally, my list would go like this:

God of War 3

Uncharted 2

Draw between Crysis 2 and Killzone 3 (for the extra controversy)

Dead Space 2

Alan Wake

Vanquish

Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm 2 (List seems awfully devoid of Japanese games)

Mass Effect 2 (This game wouldn't be on the list if it wasn't for the alien character models, fuuuuuuuuccckkk).

Final Fantasy 13 (Hate this game, only played it for four hours and then I got bored, looks dope though).

Draw between Metal Gear Solid 4, Uncharted: Drakes Fortune and Gears of War 2).

Its NOT lazy to use a single color palette.....when your on an alien planet.

Killzone's not happening on the Earth man, that is Uncharted and crysis. Killzone is happening on some alien planet that is not so good for human inhabitation and imo they have nailed the artistic graphics right on the head with killzone.

The scene and everything is captured perfectly in killzone and to this date it is astonishing to me how the hell did guerilla imagine such an amazing universe. Lightning through the skies, gaseous clouds in the sky, winds blowing throughout the region, sky colour, the water and reflections, the desert, with the quiet feeling that nobody is around you and the insects on top of that, no other game matches the artisitc imagination of Killzone in the top 5 graphical kings.

I prefer the way killzone is. I don't want it to be a rainbow Uncharted copycat, there are other games for that.

To be different, i think we should have one list for the worst graphics this gen.