But...but... they told me sales not = quality! I mean, who would be the 21 millionguys to PAY with their own hard money for something so bad?

oniyide can personally think one game is worth full price and not the other, but that does not make it an objective poor choice considering what sold more.

THIS! THIS! THIS,THIS,THIS !!!!

The game could have easly been in my top 10 best looking games this gen ONL IF IT WAS in HD! :( : (. God damnit Nintendo...

"Everything is worth what its purchaser will pay for it."
- Publius Syrius

Nooooooooooooooooo!!!Boohoo, what a liar this dude is. The internet is obviously right.

@jumpin so just because im not with the majority on this im wrong?? is that where your going with this??? so i guess anyone who didnt buy COD, GTA or whatever else sells millions is wrong. I didnt get the game at full price because I dont think it was worth it at that price. I dont give a damn what 21 million other people did.

@lordtheknight  at least you try to make sense, i respect. My issue is with some of these people being offended that i didnt like something that the majortiy liked, which is ridiculous to me. Some of them bash HD games all day i never bat an eye, it is your right to get and not get what is good for you.  People think a GTA or Uncharted sucks, fine doesnt kill my enjoyment of the game. 

Not that i think about it im gonna rethink my stance on DKCR, that game is really, really really pretty and is just IMHO a better overall game than NSMBWii, im still waiting for a price drop but not because its 2D but the game didnt just screame "buy me now" As for your DS inquiry i read it on negative.com ill find the link, but who knows how credible they are. but if you just look at the two their not really that much different and the music is the same

^^^ you still have yet to show me how much the game cost to make and why it should retail for $50   I bought GTA4 long after it came out so by default it was cheaper. (didnt own a PS3 when it was out). production cost isnt the reason why i didnt buy DKCR or NSMBWii. If you actually read my posts instead of whining, i already stated that just one of th reasons. ill give you more if it makes you feel happy, games didnt really grab me, felt that outside some nice visuuals (DKCR in this case) they didnt really do anything that i havent seen in other 2d platformers since the 16 bit era. My reasoning is my reasoning you dont like it thats your problem. and FYI everything was fine untill you came in to "rescue" Ninty yet again. 

^^^ Your first paragraph is the most sensible thing you've typed. However one, It matters to me, i dont like to feel im getting ripped off, no matter what the company. Why does it matter that the game sold 20 million copies? How does that hurt or benefit me?? I should have bought it becasue everyone else did??? By that logic you should have bought COD, GTA, Just Dance, WiiFIt, whatever sold millions. As the old axiom says if someone jumps off a bridge do you do it?? What happened to having a mind of your own???

Before you came into the thread Lordtheknight and I were having a casual conversation, he gave his points in a less than snide manner and so did I, you did come in with piss and vinegar ready to get your Hyrule sheild up. I have no problem with challenging my point, my problem is that if someone doesnt agree with you their is something wrong with them. I dont think Mario is worth the price of admission. I still think they overcharged and no one has given me any backing that makes me think otherwise and no just because 20 million people did it, thats not good enough

^^^^ Thats my point IN MY OPINION it was overpriced. I dont care if the sold 20 Mil or 20 thousand. You can scream that the demand and market was that high, but im not part of that market so therefore I saw no reason to buy the game. Im still waiting to see how much the game cost to produce im comparision to the 3D one and since your ignoring that. I would assume that A. You dont know and are just to shy to say so or B. the game to you is so awesome that price doesnt matter, which is cool. I just dont share that sentiment. 

NSMB Wii currently sits as the 14th best selling game of all time.  If the game was overpriced as you claim, then people would have refused to buy it.

If you don't think it is worth the money personally, then that is fine.  But it is the market that ultimately determines if a product was correctly priced or not.  Clearly, the market has spoken.