AussieGecko said:
|
I didnt say gaming I said movies, read comprehension is good for you.
It is more space yes, not better technology, as far as I know HD DVD was in fact that, blu-ray is more space, they are two different things. Digital distribution can in fact match them... and is. Go to torrentz.com and type in any movie or show with 1080p or 720p... matched... Not condoning piracy but that is just wrong. Proof why you think Blu-ray is going to takeover... I havent seen it yet. Ha really if you want to own a collection blu-ray is your only option, I know people that have more than 1 thousand movies on certain hard drives, if you take out crap like bonus features blu-ray discs become much much smaller, and can come down to about 1-2 gb
Actually as I said Gaming is directly linked to Movies if you are talking about a successful format, although popular, wii's discs will never catch on. It will never be the successful format, Blu-ray was used because of movies, dont seperate them please. MS makes money on every ps3 because of Blu-ray technologies, research is your friend. I would love to see proof how you think Blu-ray will last till nextgen ps because as far as the news articles seem to say the next ps is put on hold.
Considering you are currently coming back to gaming we have to talk about PS3's slow Blu-ray player, so as far as GAMING is concerned DVD's are better in spite of space, but speed. Please rip apart my arguments and explain which is baseless, this is not the first conversation I have had abou this topic. So you prefer to use a blu-ray disc to transport data rather than a hdd, if thats the case fine... you are one of the few. The majority of people seem to be skipping blu-rays and head straight to usb sticks, port hdds. No there are no games that need installing, kinect as a hardware device needs installing. Forza 3 can be played without installing... no games need installation on the 360. Tell me which games because you seem to be wrong in this case.
Optional installs yes, but that is too make the dvd drive softer and the game to run quickers its not required, you can still play the game without it.
in your brackets a better game does not make. More content, possibly, higher res textures, a better game does not necessarily need this, look at braid for example. more room for complicated programs... wtf?
|
|
I still wonder in amazement at people who feel digital distribution will become the standard within a decade or 2. We have had the internet and downloadable mp3s for over a decade, yet CDs are still produced to this day and they came out in the 80's. If anything DD and Blu-ray will co-exist. Bluray will be used by most for buying movies and will most likely be used in one form or another in gaming consoles nex gen. And DD will be mostly used for rentals and smaller Live/PSN games, like it is today. If you look at the sales of DVD plus Blu-ray vs. DD, you'll see that the majority of people prefer physical formats. Not the oppisite, as you suggested.
The cold hard fact is DD doesn't match the quality of video and sound of a Blu-ray for movies. It may say 720p or 1080p, but it is still more compressed than the info found on a Blu-ray. Granted it is getting better, but it still leaves the another thing stopping DD from completely taking over, internet speeds. There is over 40 % of people in the US who do not have a form of high speed internet in their homes. They are not going to want to download HD movies for hours, maybe even days. And if nearly half of US is lacking high speed internet, then the numbers have to be much smaller in the smaller countries around the world. Of course, you will always have people, like me, who prefer owning a physical copy of their game. No worrying about your HDD crashing and/or the compnay providing said content going out of business when you wish to redownload your movies/games.
And Blu-ray is definitely a better tech than DVDs. All Blu-rays are covered in a scratch resistant coating for added protection. A Blu-ray also reads more data per sec than a DVD (36 Mbits/s vs. 10.5 Mbits/s). This means the disc can spin at a lower speed, but read more info quickly, resulting in lower heat output and energy usage. Also, a DVD is a variable speed format, so it actually reads at different speeds throughout the disc and its max speed is mostly never realized. Blu-ray, on the other hand, reads at a constant speed throughout the entire disc. Here's a graph to compare the speed improvements.

As you can see, if a console has a 3x drive, it would hold its own against a 12x DVD player. My guess it that the PS4 will have a 4x,6x, or even 8x Blu-ray drive. This will allow games to have large amounts of content, while also helping eliminate load times. With the next gen consoles pumping put out even more graphical and audio content in each game, this space and speed is going to be required. You would be quite foolish to believe anyone is going to stick with DVD next gen. Not only would they look outdated, but no one will put up with a mandatory 2-3 DVDs required for each game. And that would be just as foolish as going DD only. No one will want to keep swapping out HDD's every few games they play. And then what happens if your HDD crashes and that content is no longer available online? Gone forever.
Also, where in the world did you get the idea MS makes money off of Blu-ray? If that was the case, don't you think they would have supported by now, and definitely instead of HD-DVD?