By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - STAR WARS TOURNAMENT - Episode 1 : The Phantom Menace (Rate it)

ishiki said:

Star Wars was always Cheesy and Awesome(Old and New)! imo (intentionally or not it doesn't matter).

The Podracing was awesome (as was the n64/pc game and the arcade game)... it had my favorite Lightsaber battle in the whole series.

And Imo, it had the best acting of the prequels, (that's not saying much at all). Yes some of it was nonsensical, but it was great fun.

My favorite prequel (And only prequel I love) and second favorite Star Wars Behind Empire Strikes Back.

9/10

What's "cheesy" is very different for each age

Episode 1 didn't seem "cheesy" when I saw it for the first time.....anakin and his mom's last scene moved me back then

Now it does seem "cheesy" to me....and anakin and his mom's last scene seems very verryyy cheesy dialogue wise...but back then it moved me a lot!



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Around the Network
darthdevidem01 said:
ishiki said:

Star Wars was always Cheesy and Awesome(Old and New)! imo (intentionally or not it doesn't matter).

The Podracing was awesome (as was the n64/pc game and the arcade game)... it had my favorite Lightsaber battle in the whole series.

And Imo, it had the best acting of the prequels, (that's not saying much at all). Yes some of it was nonsensical, but it was great fun.

My favorite prequel (And only prequel I love) and second favorite Star Wars Behind Empire Strikes Back.

9/10

What's "cheesy" is very different for each age

Episode 1 didn't see "cheesy" when I saw it

Now it does seem "cheesy" to me....but it didn't then.


i dunno well it's different for tastes too as well as age etc. It depends how serious someone takes it etc. And how they interpet it

Many of my favorite movies are cheesy to me. Like Escape from New York... *runs back on topic*



ishiki said:
darthdevidem01 said:
ishiki said:

Star Wars was always Cheesy and Awesome(Old and New)! imo (intentionally or not it doesn't matter).

The Podracing was awesome (as was the n64/pc game and the arcade game)... it had my favorite Lightsaber battle in the whole series.

And Imo, it had the best acting of the prequels, (that's not saying much at all). Yes some of it was nonsensical, but it was great fun.

My favorite prequel (And only prequel I love) and second favorite Star Wars Behind Empire Strikes Back.

9/10

What's "cheesy" is very different for each age

Episode 1 didn't see "cheesy" when I saw it

Now it does seem "cheesy" to me....but it didn't then.


i dunno well it's different for tastes too as well as age etc. It depends how serious someone takes it etc.

Many of my favorite movies are cheesy. Like Escape from New York... *runs back on topic*

I guess.

Whats your fav scene from Episode 1?



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

I give it maybe a 4, and that's being fairly generous.

I didn't find it very good at all; a big part of the movie was the whole pod race thing and I found that very boring. The only memorable lightsabre battle was with Darth Maul and it wasn't even that great. Worst in the series by far.



Xbox Live: FPSJohnFKennedy

darthdevidem01 said:
TruckOSaurus said:
darthdevidem01 said:

Who cares if its stupid....it was awesome seeing him in it

Then they should have put Luke in too! Would have been awesome seeing him in there!

If your trying to be funny, your not really......two completely different situations.

Not necessarily trying to be funny but just pushing your thought process to the limit. Unless you're making a comedy you can't put in stupid things just "because it's awesome".



Signature goes here!

Around the Network

2/10



darthdevidem01 said:

Right then.....

Before I saw Star Wars Episode 1.....

I was what 8 when this movie came out. I hated the trailers that kept airing for it....it was really annoying actually!

My dad was a huuuge Star Wars fan, his hype for this movie knew no bounds.....but he failed at convincing me to see it at the cinema's.

I remember him coming back after seeing it and saying it was ok, not as good as the old one's.

Then 2 years later we finally got the DVD for Star Wars Episode 1.....I REALLY didn't want to see the movie.....everything about it seemed off from this trailer I saw about it....I hated how the droids looked, I hated the war scenes and I hated that weird frog antelope thingy (Jar Jar binks).

But alas.....I saw it that day and it changed everything......

________________________________________________________

Now I didn't like the start....it was odd...who were these weirdo's in cloaks talking in cryptic ways....and those ugly dudes talking in a funny accent.

But I was hooked from the moment Darth Sidious came on screen with Darth Maul behind him.

And then the movie just did something for me that no other movie did.....it made me interested in its setting, world, characters, events.

I found myself CHEERING for Obi-Wan, qui-Gon and little anakin.

People found Anakin saying "yippee" annoying......but I was excited....I said yippee when he said it.....when his pod racer worked I cheered. when he said "yippee" for getting off Tatooine I was EXCITED...I was wondering what planet we'll be seeing next.....and my jaw dropped after seeing Coruscant. 

When they freed him and were leaving Tatooine I cheered....and that fight with darth Maul there was awesome

coruscant was an awe inspiring location....I was fascinated with the Senate room...all these revolving places.

It was a real adventure and I was a part of it.....I had never been so sucked into a movie in this way before.

When everyone decides to go back to Naboo from Coruscant it felt like after a long journey I was going back home to the start, in Naboo.....and what an ending it was after that with the gungan war, the duel of fates and amidala trying to get to the throne room. Darth Maul's double lightsaber.....Qui-gon's death made me cry out in shock!

It was an epic adventure....the Jedi lore amazed me, space travel...hell this began my fascination for SPACE....I had never seen such awesome special effects ever. I never cared about political drama.....but somehow I liked it in this movie.

And by the time it was over I wanted to watch it all over again.....my dad was surprised by my fascination for the movie.

If this movie WAS targeted at "kids" it did its job thoroughly well by mesmerizing me and making Star Wars my most beloved franchise in anything.....I was a "kid" then and I always become one when I see it again.

I immediately forced my parents to get me figures from the movie, I got Star Wars Jedi Power Battles for PS1...a game I adore to this day, I got the soundtrack for it.....I went crazy for it. I bought lightsaber's....all sorts of things. Its all I talked about with my friends....it changed me for better or for worse!

Now when I watch it again I can see many many maaaaaaany flaws in the movie......BUT there is no doubt this is the movie thats had the most impact on me, its the first time I felt like I was on an adventure in a movie.

This movie is my "super mario world"/"final fantasy 7"/"Gran turismo 1"........its a defining movie for me.

9.8/10

Well that's something.

It never happened to me. I'm jealous!



darthdevidem01 said:

I guess.

Whats your fav scene from Episode 1?

podracing obviously... did you read how I said the videogames were awesome. As well as it being awesome in general

As well as Natalie Portmans many crazy outfits :D

it's awesome :D



FPSJohnFKennedy said:

I give it maybe a 4, and that's being fairly generous.

I didn't find it very good at all; a big part of the movie was the whole pod race thing and I found that very boring. The only memorable lightsabre battle was with Darth Maul and it wasn't even that great. Worst in the series by far.


Want to know the really sad thing?

The pod race, what most people call the best scene in the movie, was completely irrelevant to the entire movie!

The whole bet is just plain stupid and if Qui Gonn was going to go far enough to use his Jedi powers to manipulate people, the outcome of die rolls, offer worthless things, etc (essentially lying, cheating, stealing, and just doing things Jedi don't do), then you would think it would be far easier to just take the kid rather than go through the whole convoluted bet.

It's actually amazing how terrible Qui Gonn is at pretty much everything.



Hmmm, Episode 1, not a terrible film. i give it 4.5 out of 10. i saw it after watching the originals, and i enjoyed the special effects and the fights. Darth Maul was underated, he couldve been used more imo.

but ultimately the reason its a dissappointing film is because the story is bad, and the scope of the film is small. its like a 2 day event, about a small planet, Naboo that has no significance on the galaxy. and the Trade Federation interest is unjustified. the narrative is poor, it just forces things into the film without enough forsight to work it into the script naturally eg - C3P0, landing on Tatooine, podracing. like i said the scope is small, we're taken to a galaxy far, far away so we can watch a small event that is explained using a religious prophercy.

oh and the thing i hate about this film is 'he is the chosen one'. i absolutly abhore that type of Amercain comic book stuff. its so, so, so.... Power Rangers, they're the chosen ones sent to save the world from Rita Repulsa.

so not a good film, but if there are some serious Star Wars fans on this site, let me know if you've read some of the books, because some of those are abosolutley phenominal - better than the originals imo.