so i'm an "upmarket" gamer now? okay, whatever. a name is a name. so as a representitive of upmarket gaming let me layout a few of my priorities.
HD is better than SD I have an HD TV and I've come to really like it. I pay my extra $5 or whatever it is a month to upgrade my netflix package to include blu-rays simply because not-blurry is always better than blurray.
Graphics is important This topic has many facites to consider but I want something pretty to look at. Polygon count certainly fits into this as does art style. But imo, no matter the art style more pow3r leads to better graphics. Let me tell you, Mario Galaxy would be a better game if it's graphics looked like Ratchet and Clank's. (just a game that is in a somewhat simular art style as an example).
Unified online system is great This is one of those things that I never thought was important until I got it but I love the unified online system of the ps360. Trophies and Achievments add so much fun to a game as it give me that extra incentive to really play the hell out of the games i like. Being able to see if my friends are online or not, send them messages to get them to play a game together, online co-op. All of it is great!
Controls Inputs Motion controls are great but i love my standard controller too. What I can't stand are controls that impresise (i.e. games where no matter how I play the game I get the same result on the screen also known as waggle). What I like more than anything is a wide range of experiences so don't force motion controlls where it isn't needed and do motion controlls when it make the game more better.
Unique Concepts Don't get me wrong I love me some sequels but I want fresh takes in new and sometimes even akward directions. Just a few examples of games that really impressed me with their daring this gen: wii sports, heavy rain, echochrome, flower, boom blox, demon souls. Taking a chance to satisfy a niche market instead of always going after safe games really impresses me. it lends a certain amount of "good will" to whoever delivers it.
So what you may notice on this list, is from a strickly hardware perspecive Nintendo can't deliver on many of my priorites. for me, at the start of this gen nintendo had a win in the controls inputs but the more i played the more and more disappointed i got in what could be done. especially now that ps has move and kinect is about to come out nintendo is definetly looseing this section.
I know most of you will probably just write off my opinions as i am a ps3 fanboy and all but don't forget that when I first started posting here (just after the wii released) i was a huge nintendo fanboy. thing is, i like good games better than bad games so i move to where the best of the best is and in all honestly it isn't wii games.
For me: hd first party > hd third party > wii first party > wii third party