By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Hmm...I still believe PM: TTYD is my all-time favorite Mario game

RCTjunkie on 02 December 2007
HomerS said:
i have played PM: TTYD on the gamecube and i loved it, that's why i baught the original PM now on the VC and have finished chapter 4 so far. It's also great but nowhere near as good as TTYD.
I haven't played Super Paper Mario yet but i doubt that it's better than PM: TTYD which was just amazing.

Agreed. Although SPM was good, I was dissapointed. I played the origional, too; it comes close...

WHO IS JESUS REALLY?

Around the Network
StarcraftManiac on 02 December 2007
Soriku said:
YES, it even tops SMG. I thought SMG was a little dry. It was too linear. There were no in-between quests you could do and all you could do is "collect the Stars." The music was pretty good I guess, but it's not close to topping TTYD's. TTYD had one of the best soundtracks in a game ever. The story also took a turn. While SMG's is "save the princess", TTYD's was more of a "save the princess from someone other than Bowser while experiencing different turns" and introducing more new characters than SMG. Also, I could not put TTYD down while SMG I could. But I always come back soon for SMG. Also, SMG makes me hungry ROFL. Overall, SMG is good, but not the best. I give SMG an 8.8-9.0 (undecided) comparing to TTYD's 9.7. I think just because TTYD is an RPG and SMG isn't makes a big impact to which I like. P.S. I know you guys will jump me for this X_X But that's how I feel. I'm prepared. And no, I wasn't disappointed by SMG. I liked it, but it wasn't THE BEST.

Now that i think of it... I charish good moments with that game! Maybe not my no.1 but definitely close!



THE NETHERLANDS

endurance on 02 December 2007
Soriku said:
endurance said:
Soriku said:
Surfer Girl said there's gonna be a DS PM.

actually she said theres a possibilty for a super mario legend of the 7 stars sequel for DS not a PM


 

Erm...she said a PM DS is coming, SMRPG is kinda unlikely.

hm i must of skipped that rumor,though i also doubt a PM ds is coming



endurance on 02 December 2007
StarcraftManiac said:
Soriku said:
YES, it even tops SMG. I thought SMG was a little dry. It was too linear. There were no in-between quests you could do and all you could do is "collect the Stars." The music was pretty good I guess, but it's not close to topping TTYD's. TTYD had one of the best soundtracks in a game ever. The story also took a turn. While SMG's is "save the princess", TTYD's was more of a "save the princess from someone other than Bowser while experiencing different turns" and introducing more new characters than SMG. Also, I could not put TTYD down while SMG I could. But I always come back soon for SMG. Also, SMG makes me hungry ROFL. Overall, SMG is good, but not the best. I give SMG an 8.8-9.0 (undecided) comparing to TTYD's 9.7. I think just because TTYD is an RPG and SMG isn't makes a big impact to which I like. P.S. I know you guys will jump me for this X_X But that's how I feel. I'm prepared. And no, I wasn't disappointed by SMG. I liked it, but it wasn't THE BEST.

Now that i think of it... I charish good moments with that game! Maybe not my no.1 but definitely close!


yeah it did have some awesome moments



MontanaHatchet on 02 December 2007

 



 

 

Around the Network
I like Bacon on 02 December 2007

Super Mario Galaxy is my favorite Mario game. Followed by Paper Mario, then world and SMB 3.

PM>>>>TTYD IMO.



HomerS on 02 December 2007

lol yeh the tournament was just great, also the endless dungeon with that skeleton dragon at the end, sigh good times



MontanaHatchet on 02 December 2007

I never completed the Pit



 

 

fkusumot on 02 December 2007
Soriku said:
Overall, SMG is good, but not the best.

 So what do think the best platformer is?
 



I Blame Wii Fit!

MontanaHatchet on 02 December 2007
fkusumot said:
Soriku said:
Overall, SMG is good, but not the best.

So what do think the best platformer is?


 T'ai Fu: Wrath of the Tiger.