Hmm...I still believe PM: TTYD is my all-time favorite Mario game

[StarcraftManiac]

Soriku said:
YES, it even tops SMG. I thought SMG was a little dry. It was too linear. There were no in-between quests you could do and all you could do is "collect the Stars." The music was pretty good I guess, but it's not close to topping TTYD's. TTYD had one of the best soundtracks in a game ever. The story also took a turn. While SMG's is "save the princess", TTYD's was more of a "save the princess from someone other than Bowser while experiencing different turns" and introducing more new characters than SMG. Also, I could not put TTYD down while SMG I could. But I always come back soon for SMG. Also, SMG makes me hungry ROFL. Overall, SMG is good, but not the best. I give SMG an 8.8-9.0 (undecided) comparing to TTYD's 9.7. I think just because TTYD is an RPG and SMG isn't makes a big impact to which I like. P.S. I know you guys will jump me for this X_X But that's how I feel. I'm prepared. And no, I wasn't disappointed by SMG. I liked it, but it wasn't THE BEST.

Now that i think of it... I charish good moments with that game! Maybe not my no.1 but definitely close!