4/5 It was a good press conference overall. Showed a few new titles, and showed Motion controls titles that aren't aimed at only casuals.

Was great to see the awesome Kevin Butler, and to watch Gabe Newell choke on his words.

Overall this years E3 wasn't great, but Nintendo and Sony both managed to pull it back out of the giant hole that Ubisoft and Microsoft dug.

4/5

AGENT should have been there

The start was boring and psp was neglected. But Twisted Metal is easily game of the show. Its a hard call. I'm going with a 3. 

Where's Resistance? And how dare they give GT5 so little fanfare.

Good/Great but not awesome. I'm kind of surprised that there weren't more games shown (Resistence, Trico, etc.) PSN seems kind of lame, on the other hand Playstation Move left much better impression than what Kinetc did.

All in all this E3 belongs to Nintendo, second for Sony and distant third Mircosoft. imo

I gave it 3/5.

and BTW, portal part was incrideble.

sony did ok.... 3/5

i give it a solid 4 Nintendo took this E3..but Sony had taken move to support more core gamer experiences, which is a great thing. and valve showing up was pretty cool.

kevin butler was doing his brave heart thing which was funny.

so over all a good solid presentation. and move $50.00 is pretty good price.

Twisted Metal = Win  JAK is back=WIN   3D=Win

Sorcery showed Zelda and Nintendo that wii motion plus doesn't measure up to move, sorry guys but its the truth.

4.45 because a 5 is pratically impossible.

No AGENT = disapointing

Can you go to a decimal rating? I gave Nintendo a 4/5, and Sony's was ok, not super good, but not Microsoft bad. To give it a 3 would mean that the 1/5 I'd rate Microsoft is relatively close to the Sony one, and that's not the case at all.

My opinion:

1) Nintendo

2) Sony, not a close second but not a distant second either

3) Microsoft, distant third