If i had a wii i would know what to do neither

Umm, no it's not. Play RDR. It's amazing.

Supah Mario Galaxy 2!

Here is my plan:

Kmart has a deal that gives you a copy of any Mario game on the Wii for $15 when you buy SMG2. I will spend $65 (no sales tax in my state) and get SMG2 and NSBW.

Next I will return NSBW at Walmart and get $50 store credit. I will use this $50 and pay $10 extra dollars to get RDR.

Total cost accrued-- $75 for both games. The only thing I am worried about is that I can't get to Kmart until tomorrow and they may already be sold out of SMG2.

I was thinking the same thing so I decided to buy SMG 2 from gamestop.com because of the $ 20 coupon off future purchases. You could use that for RDR.
Note: I do not know if this offer is valid outside of the USA

rent smg2, buy rdr

SMG2 has better music, sparkling graphics, gameply and it has that charm that will make people samile RDR wont do that.

I went with Galaxy 2. I've just never been a fan of Rockstar's games.

Get Red Dead Redemption and rent SMG2. RDR has infinite and addictive multiplayer (depending), SMG2 does not.

I would go for RDR if I were you, since it's a new ip. SMG2 seems like an awesome game, but if you've played the first one, you know what it's all about, so you can buy it or rent it later.