You might as well flip a coin.

You're getting both of them anyway, and both are definitely worth your money, so I don't think the order is that important.

That being said, I'm partial to SMG2 myself.

SMG2 all way the way. SMG2 is every bit better than RDR.

He said it better than I could have possibly said it.

SMG2 cos it's cheaper and nintendo games does not costume to have a discount with the pass of time, is most probably RDR have a discount... and you can even wait till RDR goes platinum

No one should ever buy a Mario game

Buy SMG2 through Amazon. The offer for $20 Video Games Credit is still on. Then get RDR with those $20 off...

You should get MG2 first, it will never get a price drop, maybe when you try to get RDR it be at a lower price.

If you get SMG2 first, just be aware that once you have it, you probably won't want to trade it in (at least I know I wouldn't).

With the multiplayer of RDR you can last for months (but it all depends ofcourse how much you like MP in games).

RDR if your interested in the multiplayer, best to get in early.

SMG2 otherwise as RDR will drop in price much faster.