Alan Wake

But I didn't start getting hyped for Red Dead until a few days ago, so I'll definitely have to get that.

I think Red Dead Redemption looks a bit better than Alan Wake.  But I will be getting neither of them for quite a long time.

Wow, I'm surprised to see AW so close to RDR :|

hmmmmmmm it looks like R* desided to position RDR to kill AW sales!.... conspiracy.......................

Well Alan Wake is going to be released 1 week earlier in Europe, so I guess I'll get AW first.
Although I'm more thrilled about Red Dead Redemption.

RDR on ps3 then halo reach later on , not buying anything but halo reach for 360 this year , well unless fable 3 gets amazing reviews

i intend to buy both, would buy red dead first because i'm a trophy whore, but there is a non-zero chance i won't get either because of galaxy 2 and mod nation are both higher on my list atm.

I'll be getting both eventually.. probably RDR first tho..

Then your not supposed to participate in this poll lol.

OT: Alan Wake. But Red Dead Redemption also is a must have.

red dead redemption on release day. I'll wait for Alan Wake reviews, and even then i'll probably wait for a price drop.