Okay. I'm going to quit looking at this thread (I keep clicking on it and looking away but I still see something that I don't want to see, every time!) and I'm going to play the game right now!

I must be the only person who was glad that John Sheppard died. I didn't like him at ALL.

Yes, he was an annoying little dick, I was hoping he was the Origami Killer so I could take pleasure in killing him with any of the 4 but ah well.

Lol, you stand on his grave the first time you meet him, how could he ever be the Origami Killer?

I didn't like him, but I didn't want him to die.

Actually, I did, because without that, Heavy Rain wouldn't exist...

Not sure how exactly now I thought about it x_x at the time it made sense :D

Also, I have to mention this. Today I went through my third playthrough, and I tried to do the trials differently. I failed the first one after about a mile of driving, I completed the second one, and then I thought I would put myself first, and back away from the third one. It made me feel pretty bad actually, but when I got to the fourth trial, my attitude had shifted more into line with that of the third trial, and when it came down to it, I felt nothing but contempt for the drug dealer, and I had no issue just killing him. I scared myself a bit there actually. Finally, I didn't drink the poison (again, putting number one before everyone else), and so I couldn't figure out the address.

My biggest disappointment in that regard, was that when I got to the warehouse (Madison called and gave Ethan the address), the ending was exactly the same as my second playthrough. Scott was praising that I had sacrificed myself to save Shaun (wtf?), and he almost shot me while I was opening the grate (saved by Norman). The only difference from my last playthrough was that I didn't manage to get Madison inside the warehouse, so Ethan was gunned down when he came out (DAMN YOU BLAKE! DAAAAAAAAAMN YOOOOOU!)

You need Jayden or Madison to be with you to not be gunned down. They have to either live or die. If it is just ethan then your screwed.

Quick question, during the fire at Scott's place when playing as Madison. Am I right in thinking hiding under the table in the kitchen gets you killed?

Also regarding endings, during all of my endings Scott has died but the stupid news people keep saying he got arrested.

@ Ajescent

I would guess so, but I can't confirm it.