Forums - Gaming Discussion - Halo 5 vs. Uncharted 4 vs. Zelda U - Reality check necrobump!

tbone51 said:
toot1231 said:
I dont think Zelda will sell as well.
its not a dark zelda so automatically will be around 2m-3m


That didn't stop WW from selling 4mil+ (and 1.2mil+ on Wiiu). Your underestimating just cuz of art style

sold way less than oot and tp

perfect example is skyward sword. even on the same platform because of the art it sold way less than tp



http://moongypsy.bandcamp.com/ ~Thank you Stefl1504 for the amazing sig~
Around the Network
eFKac said:
Expecting Halo 5 to sell the best, score the worst.
Uncharted 4 to sell second, score the best.
Zelda to sell the worst, score second.



This.



I am a Gamer... I play games and not consoles. I have a PC and Console on which I game... I like games. End of Story!

eFKac said:
Expecting Halo 5 to sell the best, score the worst.
Uncharted 4 to sell second, score the best.
Zelda to sell the worst, score second.


For scoring wise, Uncharted + Zelda always get good scores (90+), i thinkits safe to assume both will easily do it. I cant judge Uncharted, but for LoZ its getting praised for being opened world (which literally everybody wanted for over 10 years now). It might, if it still plays as well has a chance imo to be 94-96

Of Course doesn't stop Uncharted 4 as U2 got a 96



toot1231 said:
tbone51 said:
toot1231 said:
I dont think Zelda will sell as well.
its not a dark zelda so automatically will be around 2m-3m


That didn't stop WW from selling 4mil+ (and 1.2mil+ on Wiiu). Your underestimating just cuz of art style

sold way less than oot and tp

perfect example is skyward sword. even on the same platform because of the art it sold way less than tp

OoT = Best LoZ and top games of all time. TP= Wii Hype Along!

SS= Released on Dead Console+HEAVY Motion Controls.

Its not going to sell only 2mil if Wind Waker HD a remake sells 1.6mil-2mil alone. 



Metacritic:
1)Zelda= 95
2)Uncharted4=91
3)Halo5=89

First Week:
1) Uncharted 4= 3,000,000
2) Halo 5= 2,350,000
3) Zelda U= 1,000,000

Lifetime:
1) Uncharted 4= 7,500,000
2) Halo 5= 7,000,000
3) Zelda U= 5,000,000



Around the Network
Name Metacritic First Week Lifetime
Halo 5 88 3.000.000 8.800.000
Uncharted 4 92 2.100.000 7.200.000
Zelda U 95 1.050.000 4.600.000


I can see Halo 5 getting lower than 90 average while selling the best.

Uncharted in between the two in sales and score.

Zelda low sells while rated in the upper 90s.



Raziel123 said:
thx1139 said:
Seriously?

Halo 4 9+ million
Uncharted 3 6+ million
Zelda TP 6+ million on a console that sold over 100 million

With that in mind
Halo 5 9+ million
Uncharted 4 6+ million
Zelda Wii U 2-3 million


You're neglecting to take into account the ~10 million bigger install base on PS4 compared to xb1

He is neglecting to take into an account a number you just made up in your head??

The gap right now is less then 4 million and likely won't be increasing much over the next 6 months..    $399 price cut in June..  September marks the releases of 20 or so more markets..   Novermber is Halo: MCC..   Plus big titles of COD, Battlefield,  Fable and Sunset Overdrive. While the PS4 will maintain a healthy lead.. I dont think it will widen to 10 million within the next year. 



XBLive: cpg716     PSN ID: cpg716  Steam: Luv4Tech77

Predictions on 12/01/15 - Generation 8 Totals:

PS4: 85-95m
X1: 55-65m
WiiU: 20-30m

Name Metacritic First Week Lifetime
Halo 5 91 3.500.000 9.000.000
Uncharted 4 93 2.500.000 8.000.000
Zelda U 94 1.800.000 5.500.000





Won bet with t3mporary_126 - I correctly predicted that the Wii U's LTD at the end of 2014 would be closer to 9 million than 10 million. http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6673287

cpg716 said:
I am curious on how you think Uncharted 4 will sell 3 million more on the PS4... With an install base of only 15-20 million compared to 80+ million. Uncharted 2 and 3 both sound just barely 6 million copies.. and there was no growth between 2 and 3.. in fact it sold a little less copies..

I agree with your HALO 5 figure.. Halo 3 sold 11+ and Halo 4 sold about 9 mil. While the X1 console base will only be around 15m on release and maybe hit 20 m during Halo 5 lifespan could see a 8m in sales (as it would be a decline from previous outings)...


Lifetime means until it stop selling, and PS4 will be huge, Uncharted will be it's first AAA exclusive game, and yes, I expect it to surpass 9M lifetime.