All you have to do is put what score you think the game below deserves, and write a brief explanation as to why it deserves that score, hell you can even just write your opinion of the game and not add a score if you want to (which we won't add to the total of course)

Voting is open for a 1 week period, after 1 week I will count up all the scores and get the average of the game. 

Rules

1. You had to have played at least enough of the game to form an honest opinion about it

2. The larger the difference between your score and the score on metacritic; the more I expect you to explain yourself.

3. If you put more than 1 score per thread none of your scores will be counted.

4. A game must have at least 10 people that gave it a score to be counted.

5. Users with less than 50 posts cannot participate unless they have been a member on this site for more than a year.

Last game was Xenoblade Chronicles with a score of 9.24

Highest score was 10, lowest was 8

Vgchartz score --   / GamrReview score -- 8.4 / Metacritic score -- 86

VGChartz Top 15

Next game: We've received a bunch of suggestions so I'll list them here and we'll get through them all eventually. Keep suggesting new ones as well as which of these you'd like to see sooner rather than later!

Catherine, Deus Ex: HR, Forza 4, Resistance 3, Wii Party,   

To view a list of all games from every game ranking thread click here.

Thanks to Blacksaber for the awesome ranking game logo and thanks to everyone who participate(s/d).

Score: 9.5
--- You can check my GT to see that I've played the game a fair bit.

SP Campaign
--
--- Pro: Good graphics
--- Pro: Decent story, even if somewhat cliche.
--- Con: The only downside was the ridiculous amount of QTE's.

Multiplayer is where it's at:
I haven't played so much MP since 2007:
--- Pro: Graphics are top notch,
--- Pro: Controls are straightforward and responsive.
--- Pro: The Squad system works great, it's helped me win 5 games in a row at times.
--- Pro: Vehicles work well, and have been properly integrated.

8/10
single player pro's
good graphics
great sound

single player cons
was boring
things were dragged out much longer then needed.

multiplayer pro's
lots of customization
feelings of progression
co-op mode
game takes skill
Jets are fun if your a good pilot

multiplayer cons
maps are either too big or too small
maps are worse then previous incarnations, plus there are too few maps.
some weapon balancing issues
battlefield 2: modern combat on the PS2/xbox is better

5.5

I bought it two days ago! >.

2. The larger the difference between your score and the score on metacritic; the more I expect you to explain yourself. 

Metacritic score -- 86

Hmm 7.75/10
Pro: Now a bad FPS
large maps, 
decent maps

Cons: Spawning is worse than Call of Duty
SP largely uninteresting
Highly overrated and balancing teams seem to be poorly done. 

Because it is in no way shape or form the "true" Battlefield 2 sequel that EA marketing made everyone believe. It is an utter devolution of the battlefield franchise and a tragic console port. If you want an even more in depth explanation go ahead and reply again.

5 was too harsh and 6 was too generous so i decided upon 5.5.

9.4

I'm yet to finish the single-player but for multi-player BF3 is probably my favorite shooter I've played

Yeah I'd like to know more specific reasons as to why you think it's so bad.