Which FromSoftware title should get a sequel or trilogy? (Poll)

[LegitHyperbole]

KLXVER said:

LegitHyperbole said:

It'd sell PS5's. Pretty sure at this point it'd sell them as well as a GTA game. 

I think you are overestimating the popularity of the IP. Its just not anywhere near franchises like GTA. I also think an Elden Ring 2 would sell less than the first one. It was lots of peoples first From Software game and not everyone enjoyed it.

Idk, the trophy data is pretty telling, 10% platinumed. 20%, 25% and 15% for the three endings (a little higher on ps5) which would probably average higher than the usual 30 odd percent sore completion rate for a game (probably around 35-40%) in a ven diagram of who beat it only once, for comparison only 16% beat the final mission in GTA on ps4. A much shorter, much more popular game. For another comparison, 39% beat Ghost of Tsushima which is similar in length with a 9% platinum rate, very similar to what the data is with Elden Ring. 

I think people got on the hype and got hooked. I can see ER2 selling equal or more. 33% seen it through and spent the hundred odd hours to get to, level up enough and beat Melenia, this game went down well. 

Last edited by LegitHyperbole - on 01 July 2024