Best game according to my top 50 list is Nioh.

Legend of Zelda Breath of The Wild.

With Last of us as second.

I probably would have put resident evil 2 remake as 2nd if It wasn’t for the way they handled Mr X.

You're gonna get better over time. Even with my old man reflexes, stiff fingers and my hard aversion to do any kind of productive training I managed to play at GC level.

Legend of Zelda : Breath of the Wild hands down....

Halo: Reach. When it came out in 2010 (for the simple reason I don't have the MCC yet). Played the campaign several times, played it with friends and I got Xbox Live just for that game. Some of the most fun I ever had.
I'd say Skyrim is my second pick and Stardew Valley my third choice.

For me it's Super Mario Odyssey followed up by Zelda Breath of the Wild!
As for the 2d classic games, my choice go to Hollow Knight and Monster Boy and the Cursed Kingdom.

Witcher 3. Never have I been as immersed in a game as the Witcher 3. There are even secondary quests in this game that have a better plot than some games I've played.

Improved upon everything the Witcher 2 did. I'm going to play them both again, one after another during a dry spell next generation.

I probably spent the most hours on Titanfall. Easily the best multiplayer I've played since halo 3. If it had a more fleshed out campaign, could have been my... GOTG.

Easily the best mp I've played in the decade but the nod goes to the Witcher 3.

Don't forget to explain WHY it's your top pick, folks!

Yeah I'm nearing the end of the main quest now and easily one of the things that impressed me the most was the amount of effort put into even the side quests, it's insane how well fleshed out these are, compared to most games where they'd just be some guy saying "go kill 4 blue scorpions down by McDonalds."

IT's a toss-up between Bloodborne and The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. I love them both equally but for vastly different reasons.

Both are games I regularly return to and love introducing people to.
Both are a lot of fun (But again, for vastly different reasons)
Both have great worlds and lore and writing
Bloodborne has some of the best gameplay and combat in any game ever
Skyrim is great to just curl up and explore/enjoy on a whim

All these years later, I've not gotten sick of either of them yet, despite their performance-related issues.

demon souls/death stranding.  The two most immersive games i can think of, that drag you out of this world into another realm.