LOL way to derail this conversation. You said x1 has better games than ps4(which is YOUR opinion), you did not mention sales at all. But since you want to talk sales, you are comparing 3 games(2 old IPs with established fanbases, especially forza, and one new ip made by crytek) to TWO games(1 with an established fanbase and the other one a dying genre especially on sony and MS systems). Point is comparing sales is not only unfair but ridiculous. And obciously COD, AC4, AND B4 will sell better, because of established fanbases  and popularity. 

Ms pushed me away with their lack of exclusives(halo,gears and fable) can't cut it anymore

Is it an either or? I think both happened actually.

No doubt based on what exactly? Quality is subjective. The Last of Us got most of the game of the year awards last year and many people who played it said they didn't enjoy it. So, was it good or bad? Neither. It's debatable, because it's subjective. Hence random15 rightly pointing out that it's "not a fact".

I dont see it.  The general consensus about Knack was that it sucked, and Killzone is that its a decent game with great graphics.. Pretty much everything I have seen said Forza was solid, Dead Rising 3 was very good, and Ryse was a mediocre game with great visuals.   Not to mention that Killer Instinct has been begged for by its fans for years on end, and they released that at launch too.  You can have a different opinion, but that is why I feel like Xbox Ones exclusive lineup was much better, and it made no difference because last generation Call of Duty and FIFA moved all the consoles.  Alot has been made of Nintendos 3rd party problems, but as of right now Sony and Microsoft are having the same 1st party problems.  

Its both the price and the horrible reveal. More so the horrible reveal with all the bad info we were getting about no used games, always online etc.

There should be a 3rd option in the poll.

A combination of both.

Sony are trusted and MS demonstrated why they're not trusted. I still don't think there would have been that much of a difference: Cheaper, more powerful, slicker with a feature packed new controller and a focus on games.

What the hell does that have to do with anything? You keep saying it over and over, but it literally says nothing. Not to mention, as good as the gameplay is, the game came out with 6 characters and 2 will be added over an unknown (to me) period of time. A whooping 8 characters for the first season! Not to mention the price model they are using and all the features that the game is currently missing makes it feel fairly incomplete. Also, releasing at launch is not an accomplishment if the game feels rushed, incomplete or is bugged.

gamers are more informed then ever, they know ps4 is a good deal more more powerful and 100$ cheaper, it's really an easy choice for any well informed gamer that's not in love with halo/gears of war.