I'd believe it. My 360 sticks were slightly worn after only 4 years of use.

Did not say it was true just saying if this was a Xbox forum it would've been down the first day

Yeah, because it wouldn't be true.

They should close every thread that calls X1 the XBone :).

I can see the wannabe revenge but what in the world is this thread really about? I'm so lost

i could go to an x1 kiosk tomorrow, be an asshole, vandalize the equipment and make a thread about the controller being shit. The thread would be true. Now would it be locked? I dont think so. Should it be? Probably, just like the other one should have. The guy didnt have a legit complaint. 

but this thread is stupid regardless

There really isnt a lot of Xbox Fans on this site to make such threads.  There also isnt a lot of PS4 bashing on this site either.  If there is someone breaking the rules report them but the problem isnt the entire fanbase.  making a thread that isnt true just to spark a reaction isnt cool.

If you want to see a console being bashed then you may want to look at the last 7 months and xbox one, or the last year with the WiiU.

I dont believe the first sentence where it talks about the original thread was there yesterday. 

Im not going to comment about PS4's controller because i havent used it yet.  But if the original was fake talk to OP but dont blame all of Xbox Fans.

Ummm...have you checked out the GAF thread about the DS4 sticks? It's like 38 pages long about the DS4 sticks. If people weren't having problems with them then the thread would have surely died out by now.

http://m.neogaf.com/showthread.php?t=711160

Why would the other thread be closed? Seems like you wouldnt believe it unless it happened to your controller. There were a couple of posters from here right?

Agreed this thread is stupid

Why did you use two different fonts? Looks like you just copied and pasted what someone else thought about them.