I'm sure we all have at least one. Not even a guilty pleasure, but a game you adore even though it was destroyed by critics and gamers alike.
For me, it's Alone In The Dark (360), don't get me wrong, the PS2 version is garbage, but the 360 version is just so awesome in my opinion. I can get over crappy contols (I'm a Resident Evil player after all ;)) and I love how innovative it was (or tried to be). I acknowledge it's various flaws but I love it all the same.
What about you guys?